Saturday, May 2, 2020

Well, This is Bad

Here's a recent photo essay thing on The Phoblographer: Bed-Stuy which is the usual sort of thing.

Fujifilm Ambassador Jens Krauer goes on and on about what it truly means to be a street photographer, and how he just keeps coming back and back to New York over the years and he's doing this study of the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood. You'd be forgiven for thinking that he claims to have been working on his "Bed-Stuy" project for a long time, but I don't think he actually says that, and as we shall see he, um, hasn't been.

The first thing we might notice is that it is always nighttime in Bed-Stuy, that all the citizens are black, all the cops are non-black. Jens gives us a kind of noir-meets-hip-hop fantasy here. He leads with a gun, then shows us what we're probably supposed to think is drugs (is that pigeon shit in that guy's hand, or what?) what we are probably supposed to think is a hooker with her pimp, a cast of Characters, some police activity, a shrine to a murder victim, and some random urban shit.

The look is gritty and urban, standard nighttime "street" and, honestly, pretty solid examples of the genre. Spill a little gin on the ground for Weegee.

It turns out there are non-black people in Bedford-Stuyvesant, some people hardly do crime at all and daytime happens there from time to time, so this is a fantasy we're looking at, and a fantasy which is trafficking in unsavory stereotypes. This is more or less exactly the kind of thing people who worry about "representation" in photography worry about, and not without reason. This is in no meaningful way Bedford-Stuyvesant, it is at the very best a very very narrow slice of the culture there, and it is largely a construct.

But wait, there's more!

Let's run through the photos quickly and establish their locations:

Gun — no idea
Inside Shop — could be any shop, but I have a guess
man on bench — bench outside the NBA Deli at Nostrand & Halsey
window shrine — no idea
man in shop doorway — NBA deli
man on bench — bench outside NBA deli
drugs(?) — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
hulking silhouette — NBA deli
two rings — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
guy in doorway — NBA deli
people hugging — crosswalk outside NBA deli
guy getting out of car — 1-2 storefronts up Nostrand fron NBA deli
couple — NBA deli (shop door is 10 feet frame right)
dude with R — NBA deli
girl — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police activity — Arlington St, 1.5 blocks from NBA deli
broken bottle — no idea
shrine — across the street from NBA deli

A few more interesting facts. The guy in the THIS IS WHAT NEW YORK LOOKS LIKE tee is the same as the guy in his undershirt in the shop doorway. The guy getting out of his car is pointing guy, and I think also the guy holding the gun. The police action around the NBA deli is in response to the murder for the young man memorialized in the shrine. The police action on Arlington might have been the same activity (the news reports indicate they were looking for the shooter, and note that it is raining in the shot.)

These photos, which masterfully appear to be of a number of locations, are all actually taken in pretty much the same place. For more than half of them, the photographer is in the same 20 foot circle, just pointing his camera differently. The graffiti, the stickers, the foliage, and often the trash, remain the same frame to frame. These photos were, for the most part, shot within a few days of one another, on a single street corner. The cast of characters is somewhat smaller than it appears at first, you don't notice all the dupes unless you're really paying attention.

Not only is the culturally a very very tiny slice of life in Bedford-Stuyvesant, it's geographically miniscule as well.

This is some mook who's got an AirBnB for a week around the corner, and headed down to this shop two or three nights to bang out some snaps. There was a shooting one night, so he got some shots of cops doing cop shit, went out the next day to photograph the victim's shrine across the street and a few doors up Nostrand.

What really appalls me here is that he's fairly skilled.

He's taken a small set of lazily made snaps from a single street corner, and somehow managed to convincingly tell a story of crime and poverty about an entire neighborhood. Without the murder to spice things up, of course, he wouldn't have had anything much, but with it he can hang his shitty story on it, and sell it.

I mean, it's on The Phoblographer, so you know it's gonna be kind of s shit show, but seriously. This is awful.

Yes, I spent too much time on Google Street View, and reading old news reports yesterday, but honestly, it wasn't very hard to assemble all this stuff. You just have to open your eyes and look.

Thursday, April 30, 2020

Mona Lisa

Let's consider this painting by Leo, the Mona Lisa. The exact details of its origin seem to be lost, or at any rate irretrievably muddled. Still, within a decade or two of its painting it came in to the ownership the French Monarch and remained there until the French Revolution. After that point it moved to the Louvre, with a side trip to Napoleaon's bedroom for a bit, and it's been in the Louvre ever since except for when it was stolen.

The point here is that this thing has been rattling around for 500 years, more or less.

The social milieu in which the painting has resided has changed several times, even if we lump "French Kings" all together, which we probably shouldn't.

For 500 years, various and sundry cultures have looked at the painting and found in it enough worth to not throw it out. What some king saw in it in 1712 I have no idea, but I dare say whatever he saw was not in any meaningful way what I see in the painting. Probably it doesn't much resemble what Leo saw in it 200 years earlier, or what whoever commissioned it saw (if indeed anyone commissioned it.)

The thing has legs. (haw haw haw)

I don't pretend to know why this painting has managed to avoid being thrown out. It probably does not hurt that it's a picture of a person but that is certainly not the whole thing.

Consider now contemporary art.

Somewhere in the MOMA's storage facilities are things like a pile of bricks, with a sheet of paper describing how to stack them up. They paid $800,000 for this at some point. (I am making this specific thing up, but the shape of the thing is true even if the details are made up.) In its day it was, genuinely, a powerful statement of something or other by a renowned artist. The social milieu in which it was made accepted it, created it, as that thing.

Will the social milieu, the culture, of 2120, find some new value in this, find some new way to view this crated pile of bricks as valuable enough to not throw away? I don't know, but I hazard a guess that the answer is probably not. While this pile of bricks might survive the inevitable culling, many similar objects will not. Some attempt will be made to sell them, and then into the dumpster they go.

This is not an indictment of the pile of bricks. In the first place, we're stipulating that it was a Good and Important piece in its day. In the second place, the process of culling and reducing collections is inevitable. If the MOMA still exists in 2120 it will have gotten rid of a great deal of 20th and 21st century art, to make room for newer work. That art has to go somewhere, and some it will find its way into dumpsters. sic transit gloria mundi and all that.

For all art, the passage of time is a gauntlet, and all will eventually fall to the headsman. Some few pieces get more time than most. It may surprise some of you to learn that libraries discard books at a fairly brisk pace, which is why libraries do not normally explode.

Which brings us around to photography.

It may well be my snobbish sneerning nature, but I cannot shake the notion that virtually everything from about 1970 to 2020 will end up in the dustbin before 2120. Good stuff, bad stuff, whatever. Not much of it makes any sense outside of its social milieu.

Even Sally Mann (sniffle). Those Blackwater tintypes will never survive being broken out of the collection. They make exactly zero sense outside the context of the rest of Mann's oeuvre. I mean, it's not a sure thing, art lovers are weird and idiocyncratic. Maybe 100 years from now there will be some completely new read on them that continues to declare then Great Art, just as the Mona Lisa is continuously re-imagined, re-read, and maintained in the pantheon. I am not particularly hopeful about the Blackwater series, though.

Things like pretty much everything in the MACK Books catalog will, I predict, be gone inside of a decade, maybe two. The bubble of collective hallucination which sustains all art is, in this case, very small, and to my eye very tenuous.

A commenter asked me what I thought of Brad Feuerhelm's Dein Kampf and I answered somewhat glibly. Later, I watched a video leafthrough, which you may also endure here: Dein Kampf. To be fair, it's not nearly as awful as I glibly suggested. There are hints of sequence, there are references back and forth between pictures. There's citation of Pictorialism, which always warms me up to your project.

But it's still very thin. There's no pacing, no modulation, it's just a single note of "I Hate Berlin" which is a pretty overdone and not very interesting genre. Especially since, as far as I can tell, everyone loves Berlin.

Is it going to wear well? Well, like the Blackwater tintypes, I'm not seeing it. Unlike the Blackwater tintypes, it has no particular context that gives it life. To my eye, it's just out there blundering around in the dark with all the other books of German Cement marinating in self loathing to no particular purpose. Will some social milieu 50 years hence somehow latch on to it and raise it to iconic status? It's possible, but I don't see how.

I consider it possible that in 100 years Art Historians will look back on this time as the last gasp of photography. These were the decades when photography split its time between inferior copies of the early 20th century, and meaningless noise. These were the decades when photography discovered, to its surprise, that there wasn't anything there, and by around 2030 the world was, to everyone's relief, pretty much giving up on photography as a serious thing.

This isn't a viewpoint I find appealing, because I think there is a lot of juice left in the old girl. It's just that nobody's doing it, the Serious Names are all engaged in this pointless self-loathing exercise, and the amateurs are all trying to be Ansel Adams or Alec Soth, or just stuck taking pictures of bugs and milk splashes.

(present company excepted, naturally! But we are not collectively much of a movement, are we?)

I would hate to see photography lose its way not because there is nowhere to go, but because idiots keep spilling their drinks on the map.

Wednesday, April 29, 2020

The Artist You Hate

It occurred to me, as I was noodling on something or other, that everyone who thinks about art seems to have a little list of Important Names that they hate.

My list isn't even little, it's an enormous sprawling thing, but if you pay attention you'll find that this guy can't stand Alec Soth but loves Michael Ashkin, while that other guy is exactly reversed. Sometimes it's nuanced, I suppose, perhaps the first guy "gets" Soth, but simply doesn't like what he has to say, but often it seems to be just Soth's photos are just bullshit about nothing, but my guy's photos are awesome. Someone looking from the outside might well propose a pox on all their houses because, holy cow.

The liking tends to be pretty vague, too. In one discussion from a year or two back, a fellow proposed to me that Soth and some others had adopted the look of the snapshot, but within that aesthetic made things that end up being very different. Not to put too fine of a point on it, I don't follow. It's not clear that my correspondent was capable of further elucidating the "very different" elements, and I certainly don't see them. All the snapshot-aesthetic people seem to be to be taking snapshots (which is not necessarily a bad thing.)

Certainly there are photos made by Sally Mann which, taken in isolation, look like a bunch of nothing. I can do a little better, I think, than no, they're something very different in the way of explaining why I like them, but it might come out sounding to you like mystification. Even if I can, this is not really an indication that Ashkin's fans are all wet, maybe they're just not very articulate.

Anyways. As previously noted in these pages ad nauseum we evaluate Art both on the basis of properties inherent in the piece, but also on the basis of social and contextual cues.

Jörg Colberg likes Michael Schmidt's pictures of cement, I like Sally Mann's pictures of underbrush and grass, and someone apparently likes Alec Soth's pictures of drowned bedframes.

Each of us is, in some sense, inside the artist's world. We see the interconnections that give these things meaning beyond the contents of the frame.

The insight here is that in order to make someone like your pictures, you don't want to get into their world, you want them to enter yours.

Monday, April 27, 2020

A Paradox

A stupid conversation emerged on twitter. Someone, a middle-aged white dude, took exception to the idea an artist's best work is done when young. Then a bunch of other middle aged white men agreed desperately. It was like looking in a mirror after a stroke.

Anyways, anyone who spent any time being a mathematician knows that there are changes in our mental capabilities as we age. The hard truth is that if you, as a mathematician, are going to make some dizzying leap, are going to see some vital connection between two wildly differing things, are going to break some terrifying new ground, you are going to do it before your 30th birthday.

This does not mean that you become immediately at age 30. As our minds evolve, we trade in that (potential) lightning in a bottle for a steadiness, for experience, for both depth and breadth. Older mathematicians publish valuable papers, but those papers expand existing work, finish things up, clarify things, and generally steady the foundations of what has been built. Almost without exception there are no tremendous, startling, strides made by mathematicians over 50. I do not mean here only 1 in a 100 or so I mean like maybe 3 people total have made substantive creative leaps in mathematics after their 50th birthday, and I can't name any.

The young creative strives to pack enough material into their brain — barely, there's not much time — to do some explosive work before mental arthritis sets in. Later, in the fullness of maturity, they find other things to do.

Art, interestingly, reveals here a paradox.

We evaluate Art in part on the work itself, and in part on the stature and character of the Artist. This can range from a cynical well, he's in the pantheon, so if he shits in a bucket, that's Great Art to more generous greater willingness to take time with an artist you recognize. Regardless of where you fit in the spectrum of cynicism, you will find it difficult to disentangle the artist's stature from the quality of the work.

The consequence here is that as a known artist ages, and their stature rises, their Art tends to "improve" at least in the sense that it is evaluated more and more positively.

Paul Graham, aged 55, can show up with 18 substantially identical snapshots of him mum napping in a chair and get a book deal. Reviewers will scramble around muttering about the subtle differences between the frames, and how important they are, and so on. People will mumble about view cameras, despite the fact that Graham might as well have used his phone to take these things.

Objectively, Graham is lazily phoning it in. Whether he has no ideas, or whether he's simply not willing to put his ideas into a book for Micheal Mack I dunno, but his latest book is certainly pretty thin.

But his latest is nevertheless judged to be superb, because Paul Graham is in the pantheon, and he's aging and therefore getting wiser and better, right? Right?

This is what a friend of mine calls a self-licking ice cream cone. The actual work is free to vanish up it's own ass as far as anyone cares. As long as the work is not visibly the result of advanced dementia, Paul Graham (and legions of other members of the pantheon) can do pretty much whatever the hell strikes their fancy. The arc of their career is set, subject to minor in-flight adjustments.

This doesn't mean that 50 year olds are all doomed and ought to hang it up. We oughtn't. Indeed, if we didn't do anything worth a shit in our 20s, it is indeed possible that our best work is ahead of us still.

But whatever we do, it is wildly unlikely to be anything earth-shattering. Our shot at making something wildly new, something remarkable, of making some insane new synthesis of ideas that, somehow, Just Works, that's gone. That was 2 decades ago, we missed it.

Now, we can make good work ringing the changes on things we've already done, that others have done. We can clear away underbrush, we can steady the foundations.

There's plenty of excellent work to do. Just not that work.

Saturday, April 25, 2020

Book Project

This is what I've been working on. I have yet to buy a hard copy so I don't actually know for sure how it'll be, hence the pricing. Obviously if you really want a copy that bad, go for it, but I cannot in good conscience recommend it. Not only is the magazine $10,000 but blurb always gets ya on the S&H too.

Sonata No. 1 "Clematis"



Friday, April 24, 2020

Working on a Thing

I'm in progress on a thing. A thing involving these things:









I sure hope these damned things are clematis, because that's what I am calling it.

Wednesday, April 22, 2020

Good-ness, Gracious, Me

Lest anyone think I am merely picking on the hapless Mr. Colberg in the previous, allow me to remind you that the entire thrust of this stupid blog of mine from the beginning has been to work out what separates a good photo from a not good one.

Tyros seem to think that it's a collection of technical and formal qualities (focus, rules of composition, lighting patterns) muddled up with some purely subjective judgments that are beyond the ken of man. See these idiots, for example.

In reality the goodness of a photo, like the goodness of any art, is largely social, but only slightly subjective. We agree, as a community, on what is and is not good. This narrows down to as small a community as a camera club or an internet forum, or even as small as the austere community of 3 or 4 people who actually like German photo books. It grows as large as Western Society all numbly agreeing that da Vinci was quite good after all.

Well, I cannot do much socially about my own status as a pariah, so I am interested in which of these societal judgments are made on the basis of things that actually appear in the frame. Things which I could, in theory, put into the frame.

Let us back up to Duchamp and his urinal. This work is declared good because of the artist, because of his concept, because of the social construct around "Fountain." Nobody ever said Boy, what a great urinal. That's a good urinal. To say such a thing would have been to completely miss the point. See also the banana duct taped to the wall. I am not complaining here, I quite like both pieces. They are both witty, they both make a point (much the same point). I think they are both good but I do not think that the qualities in the piece itself are at all relevant.

On the other hand, we have Ansel Adams. Also in part a social construct, of course. The stature of the artist matters. However, there are formal, visual, qualities in the pictures themselves you can point to which we, as a society, have agreed tend toward goodness. As a society we think wilderness and mountains are pretty. There are formal qualities of composition leading to balance, interest, resolved tension, and so on and so forth. These are things we can observe in the picture which are, to a degree, predictors of the social response to the pictures.

I cannot be Ansel Adams, but I can put things into the picture that will tend to make people like my pictures in the same way they like his. The goodness adheres in part to the content of the piece, in ways that the goodness of Duchamp's "Fountain" does not.

Now, if I vanished into the archives of Michael Schmidt, and came out with this:



there is essentially no doubt that some people who nod wisely and say things like not his best work, of course, but it's obviously good, don't you know. And then, they would be very grumpy to learn that I shot it last night on my phone while walking my dog.

And this is the essential nub of the thing.

I am happy to stipulate that in some sense Michael Schmidt's shitty pictures of concrete, when bound in to a book, are in some sense good in the same way that Duchamp's urinal is.

If anyone can do it, though, if anyone can go to the hardware store and buy a urinal, we have to admit that the goodness in no way adheres to the work itself. It is not present in the qualities of the object.

As nearly as I can determine, anybody can churn out these dreary grey messes more or less endlessly. I seem to be able to bash them out at a few an hour. Now, if I wanted to be a proper photo-monk, I would do it with a view camera, and my rate would drop accordingly, but so what? No matter how much fuss I wrap around this sort of thing, there's no way the pictures themselves are in any way special. This isn't to say that Michael Schmidt and the Mahlers and Michael Ashkin and all these people are not making good work in some sense. I am not part of of community that judges it so, and indeed I don't get it. But there is a community that has passed judgment, and found these artists to be good.

What a community of this sort cannot do, though, is claim that the urinal itself is good. The goodness of "Fountain" does not adhere to the urinal.

Either there are qualities in Schmidt's (and Colberg's) photos that I cannot perceive, or they are in fact stampable-out like donuts by anyone with a camera. I am going to proceed thus, since, after all, I cannot perceive any such qualities. Absent these mysterious qualities, these photos can no more be good than Duchamp's urinal is in and of itself, a good urinal.

So, when Jörg pops up saying one or more of these things are good it captures my attention. It's not a statement that makes sense to me, and so I think about it, quite hard, to see if I can work out what I am missing.

If we pay attention over the next couple of years, we are going to be treated to a case study. Jörg has gotten himself a book deal, and he is indeed capable of grinding out those horrific masses of flat grey. In my judgement he has the attention, to a slight degree, of the powers that be.

If indeed there is some quality inherent in these kinds of photos, some discernible properties which the sufficiently delicate (Jörg, The Establishment) can indeed perceive, then his work should be recognized as good. If on the other hand it's got nothing much to do with the pictures, but with who you know, who your mentors were, how rich you are, and how well you schmooze, well, the mysterious qualities he sees in his pictures might not in fact propel him into the pantheon.

Nothing is certain, of course. It's always partly about how well you schmooze. But we'll be keeping our eyes open! Jörg has already sold one book, assuming it's not some 400 euro monster.