Fine Art photographers more or less give up the right to take snapshots of their kids.
Most fine arts don't truly have a vernacular form. One does not casually make sculptures about one's kids. One does not write a sonata about one's trip to Disney World. Photography does, and boy does it ever. Almost everyone makes photographs of random crap. Some artists even attempt to co-opt this stuff, making collages of found photographs and so on, trying to express some essence of Americana or whatever. The only other nominally Fine Art I can think of with a vernacular variant is fabric arts. I suppose that if you sell enormous macrame pieces for millions, you probably have to be careful about knitting socks for the cousins.
A Fine Art photographer, like any other Fine Artist, is working away at an oeuvre, a body of coherent work. That body of work has many things in it, but not too many. Enough to support the market, not enough to dilute the value. The artist's brand relies on this. Just as Rolex cannot design and build an inexpensive digital watch the Fine Artist cannot be seen as making a huge body of lower grade material. The body of work that backs up the brand must remain relatively pure if the brand is to remain valuable.
Sally Mann might have a shoebox or two full of color snapshots of her kids, but I'm gonna bet that she keeps pretty close track of them if she does.
Friday, March 22, 2013
Thursday, March 21, 2013
Clarity of Vision
One thing pretty much every successful artist has is clarity of vision. The work fits together, it's a coherent body of work. Whether the artist is truly visible in the body of work or not, the work creates the illusion that the artist can be discerned. One believes that one recognizes the work collectively as all work by so-and-so. Successful artists are not, in fact, just drunkenly welding together random piles of crap, they are welding together piles of crap in a very very purposeful way.
Whether the artist meditates naked in the rain for 24 hours before picking up a chisel, or instead simply drives forward welding, painting, cutting, toward some indefinable goal barely felt, the result is the same. The result is the product of a clear vision. Can the vision be put into words? Is the vision clear in advance, or only when the work is complete? These are not questions that particularly matter.
The clarity of vision creates the coherent body of work. The body of work is arguably the thing that matters, each piece being necessarily similar to something else we have seen. In photography this is clearly a big problem, since so many photographs already exist. In other media, comparisons can still be made: "This sculpture feels a lot like so and so, but bigger, and I sense a strong influence from what's his name" and so on. The body of work is really where the artist speaks clearly. The body of work expresses the artist's ideas, the process of creating that body of work drives forward and refines the artist's ideas. If every day is a brand new day, and you're shooting something new each day, you're not developing anything. You're not going anywhere.
The body of work is the artist's brand. Fine art is as much a branding effort as it is an artistic one, after all. Without a body of work, there's no market. A tastemaker isn't going to be happy with a single work. Why invest time and effort into an artist, unless there will be opportunity to sell other works? These other works need to be identifiably by the same artist, identifiably evolutionary work connected with previous work. Nobody wants to sell or buy a sculpture by a hot new artist only to learn that it was not a bold new work by a rising thought leader, but rather was a one hit wonder.
Commercial artists need the body of work for essentially the same reason. Nobody wants to hire a wedding photographer who's going to do something random and new every time. They want to hire a wedding photographer who is going to produce work pretty much like what's in the portfolio. Ditto fashion, and every other commercial venue. You're hired on the basis of the portfolio, which needs to be a coherent body of work which expresses something pretty specific. It is precisely that specific thing expressed which you are selling, as a commercial artist.
The only photographers with the luxury of not creating a body of work are the amateurs, and they would be well served by nonetheless working at a body of work. While there are no dollars on the line, the satisfaction of following a seam of gold to its conclusion, to developing a set of ideas and pulling together a coherent "collage" of work around them must surely have value. In particular, it's pretty much the only way you're going to make anything genuinely new.
Whether the artist meditates naked in the rain for 24 hours before picking up a chisel, or instead simply drives forward welding, painting, cutting, toward some indefinable goal barely felt, the result is the same. The result is the product of a clear vision. Can the vision be put into words? Is the vision clear in advance, or only when the work is complete? These are not questions that particularly matter.
The clarity of vision creates the coherent body of work. The body of work is arguably the thing that matters, each piece being necessarily similar to something else we have seen. In photography this is clearly a big problem, since so many photographs already exist. In other media, comparisons can still be made: "This sculpture feels a lot like so and so, but bigger, and I sense a strong influence from what's his name" and so on. The body of work is really where the artist speaks clearly. The body of work expresses the artist's ideas, the process of creating that body of work drives forward and refines the artist's ideas. If every day is a brand new day, and you're shooting something new each day, you're not developing anything. You're not going anywhere.
The body of work is the artist's brand. Fine art is as much a branding effort as it is an artistic one, after all. Without a body of work, there's no market. A tastemaker isn't going to be happy with a single work. Why invest time and effort into an artist, unless there will be opportunity to sell other works? These other works need to be identifiably by the same artist, identifiably evolutionary work connected with previous work. Nobody wants to sell or buy a sculpture by a hot new artist only to learn that it was not a bold new work by a rising thought leader, but rather was a one hit wonder.
Commercial artists need the body of work for essentially the same reason. Nobody wants to hire a wedding photographer who's going to do something random and new every time. They want to hire a wedding photographer who is going to produce work pretty much like what's in the portfolio. Ditto fashion, and every other commercial venue. You're hired on the basis of the portfolio, which needs to be a coherent body of work which expresses something pretty specific. It is precisely that specific thing expressed which you are selling, as a commercial artist.
The only photographers with the luxury of not creating a body of work are the amateurs, and they would be well served by nonetheless working at a body of work. While there are no dollars on the line, the satisfaction of following a seam of gold to its conclusion, to developing a set of ideas and pulling together a coherent "collage" of work around them must surely have value. In particular, it's pretty much the only way you're going to make anything genuinely new.
Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Collage or, What To Do When It's All Been Done
One of my favorite themes is how many photographs there are out there. Arguably, all the photographs have been made. If you don't believe me, try uploading an image into google's image search. As of this writing, it will pull out a bunch of what it terms visually similar images, and that's just exactly what it does. Given that it always seems to scrape up some startling stuff, and given that google probably has some infinitesimal fraction of All The Photographs indexed, we can learn something from this.
If every photograph has been taken (and yes, I know there are several dimensions in which this isn't and never well be true, bear with me) we still have the fact that not every photograph has been placed next to every other photograph. If we assume that there are, really, one million genuinely distinct images which can be made, then there are 1,000,000,000,000 possible pairings of images. Not all of these pairings make sense, but there seems to be a lot of potential here.
A pair of images, presented together as a piece of art or as decor, potentially says something different or at any rate larger than either piece alone. Collages, portfolios, shows, these are all new constructs which can be fundamentally new and interesting even if they are made of up things we've seen before. This suggests that one could create a show or portfolio out of other people's photographs, and yet still be making art. Copyright issues aside, of course. This has, of course, been done. Curators and editors have long been with us, perhaps we should promote them to artists? I have argued that Gary Winogrand and Vivian Maier might as well be constructs of their curators.
The general notion of a body of work, of multiple images (or pieces of art) juxtaposed is a theme I'm thinking over a fair bit these days. It's more important and central than I thought it was.
If every photograph has been taken (and yes, I know there are several dimensions in which this isn't and never well be true, bear with me) we still have the fact that not every photograph has been placed next to every other photograph. If we assume that there are, really, one million genuinely distinct images which can be made, then there are 1,000,000,000,000 possible pairings of images. Not all of these pairings make sense, but there seems to be a lot of potential here.
A pair of images, presented together as a piece of art or as decor, potentially says something different or at any rate larger than either piece alone. Collages, portfolios, shows, these are all new constructs which can be fundamentally new and interesting even if they are made of up things we've seen before. This suggests that one could create a show or portfolio out of other people's photographs, and yet still be making art. Copyright issues aside, of course. This has, of course, been done. Curators and editors have long been with us, perhaps we should promote them to artists? I have argued that Gary Winogrand and Vivian Maier might as well be constructs of their curators.
The general notion of a body of work, of multiple images (or pieces of art) juxtaposed is a theme I'm thinking over a fair bit these days. It's more important and central than I thought it was.
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Outgrowing Cameras
A remarkably common theme on internet forums, and probably almost as much in the days before them, is this notion of outgrowing a camera. You might buy an entry level camera, and then outgrow it, and need to upgrade to a new camera.
This is a wonderful idea for camera companies, of course. It's also a wonderful idea for many amateur photographers, the ones who like cameras more than they like photographs.
The implication of the term is that as your skills grow, your camera will begin to hold you back. This can actually happen with some devices and systems. When racing sailboats at some point it may make sense to acquire a faster boat. Generally speaking a slightly slower boat isn't going to be the limiting factor, your terrible steering and bad tactics are why you're losing races. If you work at it, though, you will find that you're doing everything right and still losing the races by a couple of seconds to the other fellow who is also doing everything right and who has a slightly faster boat. A golf club, I imagine, might hold you back. After your swing becomes perfect the inaccuracy of the club is the limiting factor in placing the ball onto the green.
These things simply don't happen with cameras. Well, there are probably some weird corner cases where you could make an argument, but as a general thing your skills do not expand to the point that the camera is limiting you.
What happens is that your taste and desires become refined and more precise, and you learn what manner of photographs you would like to take. Then, in some cases, you will find that a different camera is what's necessary to make those photographs. If your desire is to shoot sports, you may really need a higher burst frame rate. If you want to shoot wildlife, you will want longer lenses (and longer, and longer, without end). If you want to shoot in low light, you may truly need a better sensor.
There are reasons to upgrade. "Outgrowing" a camera isn't really one of them. Perhaps this is the best word we have available to describe the refined tastes and desires, but it still doesn't fit.
If you want to upgrade because, hey, shiny new toy, that is ok. It's disingenuous to assert that you've outgrown the old one.
This is a wonderful idea for camera companies, of course. It's also a wonderful idea for many amateur photographers, the ones who like cameras more than they like photographs.
The implication of the term is that as your skills grow, your camera will begin to hold you back. This can actually happen with some devices and systems. When racing sailboats at some point it may make sense to acquire a faster boat. Generally speaking a slightly slower boat isn't going to be the limiting factor, your terrible steering and bad tactics are why you're losing races. If you work at it, though, you will find that you're doing everything right and still losing the races by a couple of seconds to the other fellow who is also doing everything right and who has a slightly faster boat. A golf club, I imagine, might hold you back. After your swing becomes perfect the inaccuracy of the club is the limiting factor in placing the ball onto the green.
These things simply don't happen with cameras. Well, there are probably some weird corner cases where you could make an argument, but as a general thing your skills do not expand to the point that the camera is limiting you.
What happens is that your taste and desires become refined and more precise, and you learn what manner of photographs you would like to take. Then, in some cases, you will find that a different camera is what's necessary to make those photographs. If your desire is to shoot sports, you may really need a higher burst frame rate. If you want to shoot wildlife, you will want longer lenses (and longer, and longer, without end). If you want to shoot in low light, you may truly need a better sensor.
There are reasons to upgrade. "Outgrowing" a camera isn't really one of them. Perhaps this is the best word we have available to describe the refined tastes and desires, but it still doesn't fit.
If you want to upgrade because, hey, shiny new toy, that is ok. It's disingenuous to assert that you've outgrown the old one.
Tuesday, March 12, 2013
Thumbnails
I am increasingly testy about the modern habit of printing everything very large. It strikes me that this is an effort to wow the viewer with a mass of detail and the sheer bigness of the thing, and to conceal thereby the lack of content.
There's more to it, though. There is a definite field of view that we can apprehend "all at once" and it is surprisingly small. By making large prints and then hanging them in such a way as to force us quite close to them, the artist alters the way we see the work. We have to scan it, and mentally assemble the image. Our visual cortex helpfully does all the heavy lifting for us, and in general we're unaware of the scanning process unless the print is very very large indeed.
Let's imagine we're in a museum, looking at prints on the wall. Let's say we're something like 8 feet away from the wall. My experience with museums suggests this is a pretty typical viewing distance, plus or minus a few feet.
The width of the visual field we're conscious of is something like 40 or 50 degrees wide (this is the view a "normal lens" gives on a camera). To see a wider area than this, we deliberately turn our head from side to side. In the museum, if the print is more than about 5 feet wide or so, we're going to have to start doing this, or we need to step back.
The field of view we can actually grasp "all at once" in some useful sense, seems to be much smaller. Let's say about 5 degrees (experiment yourself, fix your eyes on the page, estimate what you can actually see clearly without letting the eyeball move, and do the math). This corresponds to a print size of about 8 inches across at our 8 foot viewing distance. Call it an 8x10 print, since the stuff around the edge of the frame probably isn't very important. We can grasp the essentials, the central portion, of an 8x10 in one go if we're 8 feet away. More or less.
There's a great deal of daylight between the 8x10 print and the 5 foot-wide prints you have to consciously scan to grasp, and this is pretty much where everyone is printing these days. With the typical 16x24 and up prints, our visual cortex is working harder. We're assembling a notion of the forms in the print with peripheral vision, and unconsciously scanning to fill in detail here and there, and over the course of a couple of seconds building up a clear picture of the image. What's really interesting here, by the by, is that it feels instantaneous because we're editing our memory to obscure the time lag. Look up chronostatis for the details.
Finally on to the subject of this piece. Thumbnails are a new thing. They belong to the Internet, they originated there and are a uniquely digital artifact of the way we organize and present images. They're small, which is the point. They're small enough to apprehend in one go, we see them in an instant. While we see them in an instant, they also have certain properties akin to a very large print, in that they are really a low-resolution summary of the image in the same way our peripheral vision provides a low-resolution summary of our current field of view.
It doesn't happen to me very often, but occasionally the thumbnail presents a very clear idea of the image I am about to look at, which is completely wrong.
Always, the thumbnail provides a wildly different experience of an image. In pretty much all cases, I find that the thumbnail tells me if the photograph is any good. That is, if I like the thumbnail, I will like the photo, and if not, I won't. But not always.
There's more to it, though. There is a definite field of view that we can apprehend "all at once" and it is surprisingly small. By making large prints and then hanging them in such a way as to force us quite close to them, the artist alters the way we see the work. We have to scan it, and mentally assemble the image. Our visual cortex helpfully does all the heavy lifting for us, and in general we're unaware of the scanning process unless the print is very very large indeed.
Let's imagine we're in a museum, looking at prints on the wall. Let's say we're something like 8 feet away from the wall. My experience with museums suggests this is a pretty typical viewing distance, plus or minus a few feet.
The width of the visual field we're conscious of is something like 40 or 50 degrees wide (this is the view a "normal lens" gives on a camera). To see a wider area than this, we deliberately turn our head from side to side. In the museum, if the print is more than about 5 feet wide or so, we're going to have to start doing this, or we need to step back.
The field of view we can actually grasp "all at once" in some useful sense, seems to be much smaller. Let's say about 5 degrees (experiment yourself, fix your eyes on the page, estimate what you can actually see clearly without letting the eyeball move, and do the math). This corresponds to a print size of about 8 inches across at our 8 foot viewing distance. Call it an 8x10 print, since the stuff around the edge of the frame probably isn't very important. We can grasp the essentials, the central portion, of an 8x10 in one go if we're 8 feet away. More or less.
There's a great deal of daylight between the 8x10 print and the 5 foot-wide prints you have to consciously scan to grasp, and this is pretty much where everyone is printing these days. With the typical 16x24 and up prints, our visual cortex is working harder. We're assembling a notion of the forms in the print with peripheral vision, and unconsciously scanning to fill in detail here and there, and over the course of a couple of seconds building up a clear picture of the image. What's really interesting here, by the by, is that it feels instantaneous because we're editing our memory to obscure the time lag. Look up chronostatis for the details.
Finally on to the subject of this piece. Thumbnails are a new thing. They belong to the Internet, they originated there and are a uniquely digital artifact of the way we organize and present images. They're small, which is the point. They're small enough to apprehend in one go, we see them in an instant. While we see them in an instant, they also have certain properties akin to a very large print, in that they are really a low-resolution summary of the image in the same way our peripheral vision provides a low-resolution summary of our current field of view.
It doesn't happen to me very often, but occasionally the thumbnail presents a very clear idea of the image I am about to look at, which is completely wrong.
Always, the thumbnail provides a wildly different experience of an image. In pretty much all cases, I find that the thumbnail tells me if the photograph is any good. That is, if I like the thumbnail, I will like the photo, and if not, I won't. But not always.
Monday, March 4, 2013
Photography as Consciousness-Raising
We see a lot of pictures of homeless people. This is usually justified as some sort of social commentary or consciousness-raising exercise. Some good background reading here, by the by, is Sontag's little book Regarding the Pain of Others which as usual isn't exactly the last word here but will get you to think of some stuff.
Most photographs don't change the world. We sort of think that they do. "Migrant Mother" and so on we think of as important photographs that were the prime movers of certain important changes. This isn't really true, and as a consequence, photographing homeless people isn't just trite and exploitive, it's (mostly) useless.
First of all, try to think of all the iconic world-changing photographs you can. Can you think of ten of them? I can think of perhaps four or five off the top of my head.
Now subtract out all those photographs that were in the hands of a skilled propagandist, that were used as a part of a larger campaign, which campaign was applied to a population that was poised to change already. Are there more than zero left?
We think of the pictures as the prime movers because they're the thing we remember. We don't really remember the speech as well. We don't remember the editorials. We don't remember the mood, and the idle conversations that encapsulated our mood and the mood of the society. We are visual creatures, and so we remember the picture.
Your photograph of the homeless guy isn't going to set the world on fire. It might, though, persuade a couple of your friends to give a few bucks to the local shelter, and that's certainly not a bad thing.
You could make the argument that (as noted above), in order for society to make profound changes it must be ready to change. Perhaps photographs of homeless people prepare society for these changes. Perhaps my photographs of poverty help with the gradual, imperceptible shifts of attitude which render the society ripe for change at some unknown future time? This is not an unreasonable hope, but it is a bit tenuous.
One could as well argue that the constant stream of photographs of the homeless and impoverished instead desensitize us. We react to these photographs in a variety of ways: Gladness that it is not us in the photo, a desire to change and improve the lot of the people in the photograph, a contrary desire to leave things exactly as they are in hopes that we will not end up like the person in the photograph, and probably many more. These reactions can, of course, overlap. Humans are fully capable of exactly contradictory and simultaneous emotional responses.
Ultimately, the ways in which societies change and evolve seems to be too subtle and complex for us to understand at this time. Arguments that our pictures aid this change, or direct these changes in a particular direction, are therefore a bit suspect at best. They are hopes and aspirations, not really arguments.
Should you photograph the homeless? I can't answer that. The question is complex and difficult, though. The answers are not obvious. Your motivations as a photographer are certainly not clear to us, the viewer, and it seems likely that they are likewise unclear to you, the photographer.
Most photographs don't change the world. We sort of think that they do. "Migrant Mother" and so on we think of as important photographs that were the prime movers of certain important changes. This isn't really true, and as a consequence, photographing homeless people isn't just trite and exploitive, it's (mostly) useless.
First of all, try to think of all the iconic world-changing photographs you can. Can you think of ten of them? I can think of perhaps four or five off the top of my head.
Now subtract out all those photographs that were in the hands of a skilled propagandist, that were used as a part of a larger campaign, which campaign was applied to a population that was poised to change already. Are there more than zero left?
We think of the pictures as the prime movers because they're the thing we remember. We don't really remember the speech as well. We don't remember the editorials. We don't remember the mood, and the idle conversations that encapsulated our mood and the mood of the society. We are visual creatures, and so we remember the picture.
Your photograph of the homeless guy isn't going to set the world on fire. It might, though, persuade a couple of your friends to give a few bucks to the local shelter, and that's certainly not a bad thing.
You could make the argument that (as noted above), in order for society to make profound changes it must be ready to change. Perhaps photographs of homeless people prepare society for these changes. Perhaps my photographs of poverty help with the gradual, imperceptible shifts of attitude which render the society ripe for change at some unknown future time? This is not an unreasonable hope, but it is a bit tenuous.
One could as well argue that the constant stream of photographs of the homeless and impoverished instead desensitize us. We react to these photographs in a variety of ways: Gladness that it is not us in the photo, a desire to change and improve the lot of the people in the photograph, a contrary desire to leave things exactly as they are in hopes that we will not end up like the person in the photograph, and probably many more. These reactions can, of course, overlap. Humans are fully capable of exactly contradictory and simultaneous emotional responses.
Ultimately, the ways in which societies change and evolve seems to be too subtle and complex for us to understand at this time. Arguments that our pictures aid this change, or direct these changes in a particular direction, are therefore a bit suspect at best. They are hopes and aspirations, not really arguments.
Should you photograph the homeless? I can't answer that. The question is complex and difficult, though. The answers are not obvious. Your motivations as a photographer are certainly not clear to us, the viewer, and it seems likely that they are likewise unclear to you, the photographer.
Friday, February 22, 2013
Diamonds, Fashion, and Fine Art
Why do some of us get so cranky when some crummy photograph sells for millions of dollars?
Consider the diamond. This is a more of less common rock (not common everywhere, but where they are found there are lots and lots and lots of them) which is easily synthesized. For some reason, though, diamonds are very expensive. Why?
For social reasons, we as a society want them to be expensive. The social reasons are carefully nurtured by DeBeers but belong essentially to us. DeBeers and society as a whole conspire to keep the supply of diamonds artificially restricted, so that they remain expensive. The diamonds we own remain valuable in some sense, and we enjoy the romance of the diamond as thing. Everybody wins. Well, except the guys digging the diamonds out of the ground.
In the same way, we as a society and those members of our society who are very rich, want there to exist very very expensive pieces of art. The rich want to possess things of rarity and value, and the rest of us want to cluck our tongues disapprovingly or to enjoy fantasies of being rich. The trouble with art is much the same as the trouble with diamonds -- there is just so damn much of it. How on earth can art be valuable or, more to the point, expensive, when it is being produced by the trainload on a more of less daily basis all across the world? Art isn't as common as mud, but it's pretty common.
You do it the same way you make diamonds valuable. You invent gatekeepers and tastemakers to artificially restrict the supply of Art, or at any rate Fine Art. These gatekeepers are primary market collectors, curators, and so on. Their job is similar to that of a fashion designer, they must have an intuitive grasp of what the market is ready for. They must discover new artists and new art at the right rate, to keep the market supplied while keeping prices up. The art must be novel, but not too novel (markets are always ready for something new, but never for something too new). Ideally, it would also be good -- whatever that means. Surely the gatekeepers strive to find good art, of course they do. Still, when a million bucks is on the line we are justified in speculating that closing a deal might take priority over good.
New art must of course be justified as good. Nobody wants to buy a piece that's bad. Happily, the art world comes free with a more or less infinite supply of technical jargon and meaningless phrases which can be used to justify practically anything as good. To reiterate, any piece might well be good, but the point is that it needs to be seen as good. Always assuming that previous sentence means anything at all.
And so we have things like Gursky's Rhine II, which might be good, might be bad, I don't have an opinion. Any competent technician could have made it, and the concept doesn't strike me as particularly strong. It's printed really really big, though. Does it evoke something? Certainly not any more, now all it evokes is HOLY CRAP FOUR MILLION DOLLARS?!! The Fine Art world has successfully destroyed this as a piece of actual art.
We have Cindy Sherman's Untitled #96 which, like all of Cindy Sherman's work, appears to be the work of a not very bright college sophomore (this is at least in part because not very bright college sophomores tend to copy Sherman and her derivatives). This one is a trifle under four million dollars.
It doesn't matter, though. Gursky and Sherman are valuable because they are expensive, and expensive because they are valuable. Whether they are good or bad, or what those words even mean, is entirely irrelevant. The Fine Art world demands it, we demand it as a society, and the gatekeepers and tastemakers can only do their best at supplying what is demanded. Everyone makes a tidy profit, everyone's happy.
It's not fair that artists are selected essentially at random to win the Fine Art lottery, but what can you do? That's how it is.
Consider the diamond. This is a more of less common rock (not common everywhere, but where they are found there are lots and lots and lots of them) which is easily synthesized. For some reason, though, diamonds are very expensive. Why?
For social reasons, we as a society want them to be expensive. The social reasons are carefully nurtured by DeBeers but belong essentially to us. DeBeers and society as a whole conspire to keep the supply of diamonds artificially restricted, so that they remain expensive. The diamonds we own remain valuable in some sense, and we enjoy the romance of the diamond as thing. Everybody wins. Well, except the guys digging the diamonds out of the ground.
In the same way, we as a society and those members of our society who are very rich, want there to exist very very expensive pieces of art. The rich want to possess things of rarity and value, and the rest of us want to cluck our tongues disapprovingly or to enjoy fantasies of being rich. The trouble with art is much the same as the trouble with diamonds -- there is just so damn much of it. How on earth can art be valuable or, more to the point, expensive, when it is being produced by the trainload on a more of less daily basis all across the world? Art isn't as common as mud, but it's pretty common.
You do it the same way you make diamonds valuable. You invent gatekeepers and tastemakers to artificially restrict the supply of Art, or at any rate Fine Art. These gatekeepers are primary market collectors, curators, and so on. Their job is similar to that of a fashion designer, they must have an intuitive grasp of what the market is ready for. They must discover new artists and new art at the right rate, to keep the market supplied while keeping prices up. The art must be novel, but not too novel (markets are always ready for something new, but never for something too new). Ideally, it would also be good -- whatever that means. Surely the gatekeepers strive to find good art, of course they do. Still, when a million bucks is on the line we are justified in speculating that closing a deal might take priority over good.
New art must of course be justified as good. Nobody wants to buy a piece that's bad. Happily, the art world comes free with a more or less infinite supply of technical jargon and meaningless phrases which can be used to justify practically anything as good. To reiterate, any piece might well be good, but the point is that it needs to be seen as good. Always assuming that previous sentence means anything at all.
And so we have things like Gursky's Rhine II, which might be good, might be bad, I don't have an opinion. Any competent technician could have made it, and the concept doesn't strike me as particularly strong. It's printed really really big, though. Does it evoke something? Certainly not any more, now all it evokes is HOLY CRAP FOUR MILLION DOLLARS?!! The Fine Art world has successfully destroyed this as a piece of actual art.
We have Cindy Sherman's Untitled #96 which, like all of Cindy Sherman's work, appears to be the work of a not very bright college sophomore (this is at least in part because not very bright college sophomores tend to copy Sherman and her derivatives). This one is a trifle under four million dollars.
It doesn't matter, though. Gursky and Sherman are valuable because they are expensive, and expensive because they are valuable. Whether they are good or bad, or what those words even mean, is entirely irrelevant. The Fine Art world demands it, we demand it as a society, and the gatekeepers and tastemakers can only do their best at supplying what is demanded. Everyone makes a tidy profit, everyone's happy.
It's not fair that artists are selected essentially at random to win the Fine Art lottery, but what can you do? That's how it is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)