Thursday, February 13, 2014

It's a Golden Age of Photography

Inspired by smogranch, who is awesome.

It is, it truly is.

There was a time and a place when being literate, simply being able to read and write, was sufficient to earn a living. There was a whole lot of learning involved. You had to know how to make and maintain pens made out of feathers, and probably how to compound ink. Lettering was quite complex. You might have had to know some Latin.

These days most of that has been swept aside. We buy ballpoint pens and throw them away when the ink runs out. Lettering is simplified, and the standards for adequate lettering are mostly non-existent. We write mostly on computers, anyways. You can still get paid to read and write letters for people, but it's rare and making a living at it is nigh impossible. In the first world nations, and increasingly across the globe, "everyone" can read and write.

This is considered a good thing by all thinking human beings.

There's a science fiction novella called Gunner Cade in which the title character joins the military of the future. The details elude me, but, roughly, he undergoes years of training based around The Gun, a sort of energy pistol which is the weapon of the soldier of the future. Loads of technical detail, maintenance routines, a quasi-religious set of rituals around The Gun. Later, Cade joins a revolutionary group that has acquired a large supply of these Guns, and he is charged with training the rag-tag group in their use.

At first he is daunted, this takes years! Then he sorts through his training, and trims it down to the essentials for the job at hand which is winning this battle. His training regime is thus reduced to:

Grab a Gun.
Turn it on with this switch.
Point it and pull the trigger. When it stops firing, throw it away and grab another Gun.


Mastering The Gun does not take years, after all. It takes seconds. Does this sound at all familiar?

Spoiler: Cade's side wins.

We now live in a similar golden age of photography. Everyone can take pictures. A few people think this is terrible, woe, the standards have fallen so, etc etc.

In the first place the standards haven't fallen all that much. Sure there's daylight between what a "professional" would have done and what some bozo with a cell phone does, but it's daylight that doesn't matter to anyone.

We might, for instance, see fatuous idiots explaining that the standards for prints are, really, 300dpi, and your picture will only print 1 inch across! The correct response is a blank stare and "but I just want to stick it on facebook. print? what?"

We might, for instance, see another fatuous idiot explaining that without a DSLR and a fast lens, you'll never get good bokeh, and the subject will never be really well separated from the background. One can either go straight to the blank stare and "I don't care. In fact, nobody cares, except you" or you could, for extra fun, pull the picture into an editor and hastily blur the background.

At this point the fatuous idiot will point out that the blur doesn't look like convincing focus blur. Then you get to point out that the mission is to make the subject separate from the background, not to simulate a full frame whateverthefuck and an 85/1.8 GLZ whateverthefuck lens. Did you want to separate the subject or were you just trying to justify your $4000 camera kit?

"Nobody cares, except you."

Most of the difference between self-styled expert photographers and the bozos with the cell phone cameras is pointless ritual aimed at producing effects most people cannot even see without training, and optimizing parameters nobody cares about. You don't need to know how to mix collodion, or what sodium thiosulfate is, or what the aperture setting does.

It's a golden age of photography. Anyone can take pictures. Anyone can take excellent pictures. You just stand in a good place, point the camera in a good direction, and pull the trigger.

Isn't it great?

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

It's a Web Of Pictures

People don't read, on the world wide web.

Well, that's not quite right. Still. Find yourself a context in which people can write things, and other people can reply to those things. Write some sort of thoughtful remark, say 200 words or so. Make sure it's on-topic, that is makes a single clear point, and that it backs that point up with a straightforward argument. Now watch for replies. You might have to do this a few times to actually draw a reply.

Almost invariably you will find that even a direct reply -- someone hit a "reply" button, and perhaps quoted some or all of your text -- will make almost no sense. It won't be a reply at all. You might ask yourself if the replier is insane, since your point was quite clear, and yet the reply seems to be about something else entirely.

People don't read, on the web. They're here to kill time, they're here on mobile devices that make reading text quite a chore. One could probably perform a study to measure the average amount of time people will devote to trying to read and grasp a comment, a forum remark, or any other "flow of conversation" snippet of content (as opposed to, say, a longer form news article). I bet the answer would come out to a small number of seconds.

People don't read. Instead, they skim. They pick out keywords and phrases, they try to guess what your position is based on that. They may slot you into a social group "my side" or "their side" if there's some sort of argument going on. Based on this sort of snap judgement, they will they dash off a reply based not on what you said, but what they imagine someone like you might say.

Ok, so what? Andrew's a damn crybaby, and nobody bothers to read what he wrote.

The important point here is that people allocate a very small number of seconds to some content you post. So, you're best off posting a picture.

If you write: went to a party last night, drank too much, it was awesome. Hung out with Billy and Susie, and laughed and laughed. Now I am hungover. people might read it. They might not. It's an impossibly tiny fragment of impossibly tiny text on their iPhone.

If you post a picture of you and Susie and Billy laughing very hard and visibly drunk, you communicate exactly the same thing, and people reading your social media thing will grasp the idea reliably and instantaneously. There is zero effort involved, no reading, no puzzling out of tiny letters. Instead of engaging a linear/reading part of the brain, what's engaged is the picture-recognizing parts of the brain, which work all-at-once.

Memes are somewhere in the middle. There's a picture, but there's words. What's nice about memes is that the structure of the picture with words on it enforces both a large font (easily read on mobile devices) and a very short lump of text (quickly read). It's not quite as instantaneous as a picture alone, but it is grasped by the reader very very fast indeed. It is a fine way to make some point in, nearly, an instant.

It's a world wide web of pictures. It's what people want, it's what they consume.

Hooray, photography for the win! (as civilization crumbles!)

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Inspiration/Perspiration. A Worked Example.

A couple of relevant essays I have written in the past: pre-visualization and inspiration and a post on terminology I am citing a lot since I am using some pretty specific and idiosyncratic terminology. You may have read them before, and they're not mandatory pre-requisites. Just precursor material to what follows here.

Over the weekend, I had some time, so I decided to perform an exercise.

I would select an object, at random, and attempt to discover an inspiration, a eureka moment, in how to shoot the thing. The process here is, as I have noted in the past, to alternately think about the problem, and to take breaks from thinking about the problem, until a solution pops into one's mind. This can take a while. In this case, it was a day or two later that my inspiration occurred, such as it was.

The object I selected was my wife's bicycling helmet. I started out looking at it, pondering it in a fairly vague sort of way. I shot a couple pictures of it with my phone:



Pretty uninspired, but the idea was to simply have a record shot so I would know what the thing looks like. After noodling on it a bit, I moved on to other things.

Over the course of the next couple of days, I came across the pictures on my phone a couple of times, and noodled some more. My usual technique is to simply bury the thing in shadow. Heavy chiaroscuro and call it good, but I wanted to not simply revisit old tricks with this exercise.

At some point a couple of days later came the inspirational moment. Not a big one, just a little "aha!". It went like this:

I was thinking, for the second or third time but I don't want to just bury it in shadow when the critical thought occurred the holes, something about the holes. My first idea, discarded almost immediately, was to skim a light across the top, burying the holes in shadow. A white helmet with inky black holes. The next idea was no, put a light inside it, and have rays of light beaming out from each of the holes! I forget precisely the circumstances, but I may have been on the verge of sleep when this happened. That's typical. Showers and baths are also good times. After a sufficiently long period of thinking about the problem, and resting (not thinking), a proper period of restful, semi-conscious, vague thought on the problem can often cause a solution to bubble up to consciousness.

This was the concept I had in mind today when I revisited the helmet to actually shoot it. That was the moment of inspiration -- the holes! Now we get to perspiration and serendipity, and how ideas don't always work out the way you envisioned.

I set up the helmet with a flash inside it, and took some shots to calibrate composition and exposure, roughly.



That sucks. You can see the flash, and there's no light coming out most of the holes. Let's wrap that flash up in a pillowcase and reposition a bit.



That's more like it. Now for some rays. Hmm. What happens if we spray a water mist around? I had a feeling this part was not going to go as planned, and I was right -- making well defined "light rays" is something I have not mastered. Or apprenticed. Or even started figuring out, really. It's a total mystery to me.



Ok. Huh. That's not really at all what I envisioned, but it's definitely something. I'll take it! Crop out the ugly bits, tighten it up a bit, dodge up some of the features of the helmet and vignette gently to close up the frame, and call it done:



Inspiration, brought about by planting a problem firmly (How shall I shoot this object) and then alternately thinking hard about it and relaxing and thinking about other things, or nothing at all. A couple days later, inspiration (holes, light rays). Perspiration, actually try to shoot it, tinker with what we have on hand. Work toward your inspired solution, but be open to possibility.

The result is recognizably me. There's a lot of shadow around, there's a lot of inky blackness, but it's not just a copy of something else I've made. The result is something I am OK with.

Now there's a visual idea in play. You can invent some meaning to go with it, and to build a portfolio around. Perhaps we are envisioning the athlete a glowing force. We shoot sporting equipment with the athlete represented by brilliant light. We bring in environmental cues to suggest rain, wind, sleet, mud, to express some notion of athleticism in the elements, in tough conditions, against difficulties. One picture doesn't suggest this idea at all, but 4 or 5 or 10 would make the concept quite clear, and now we have a portfolio that's saying something.

An idea that is unclear in a single picture can be made obvious across a series of pictures, a portfolio. Or a campaign.

There are probably other equally strong ideas, I don't know. This is the idea that occurs to me right now. If I wanted to pursue this theme I might well try to build a portfolio around these ideas -- these kinds of subjects with these kinds of ideas carried by one or more renderings. As for use I don't know. This feels like a prototype for some kind of advertising campaign, perhaps.

And that's how I do it. Perhaps it will help you find your own process for inspiration.

On the Use of Processes

A process is a set of steps that produce a more or less predictable result.

If I shoot black and white film, develop it according to directions, and then take some more steps with some more materials, what results is black and white prints. If my process involves placing a flower in front of the camera, my process is one which produces pictures of flowers.

There are tons of photographers with processes that relate to subject or rendering, often both. Most so-called street photographers have a process that involves setting their camera to black-and-white, and then taking pictures of people outside in an urban environment. This produces, surprise, black-and-white pictures of people in an urban environment. To many photographers, that's what street photography is.

Other photographers have processes that are about light, or lighting. These people will urge you to Master The Light or something similarly fatuous. Among these guys, consider the 500px-popular landscape photographer. These landscape guys might have a process that involves waiting for certain times of day, certain weather conditions, and so on, and then taking wide angle pictures of land. Or water. Or whatever. Then they might apply a process of photoshop activities. The final result is usually more or less the same as everyone else's landscapes. It's brightly colored, it's pretty, the moving water is rendered as a freakish mist, and the whole thing would look terrible on a giant canvas wrap print above the couch.

The trouble with all these processes is that they are all about subject and rendering.

If you want to produce pictures that look a certain way, if your goal is to make pictures that look like Peter Lik's, or Eric Kim's, then your process should be about subject and rendering, because that's all these guys have going on. You follow their process, you get their results. You add a little of your special sauce, you get their results with special sauce. It's pretty straightforward. It's not my thing, but if it is your thing, you shouldn't be ashamed. Well, no. You should be ashamed of yourself, but only a little bit. It's ok, we all have faults.

If you want to produce pictures that have a certain idea, a certain feeling, a certain emotion, and you want them to make more than one picture that connects to the same idea, feeling, or emotion, then a process is a good idea here as well. It's just not a process that's entirely about subject and rendering, it's about idea and use as well, where I use all these words in the sense defined in the linked essay.

Another way to put this is that if you have a clear idea in mind then your pictures have a chance of being connected at that level, of all expressing the common idea, or facets and variations on that common idea. It is likely that subject and rendering will tend to follow along as well, since idea is really expressed through these, but it it by no means certain. A portfolio which uses a handful of radically different subjects and renderings to express similar ideas is going to be pretty interesting, and certainly won't suffer from the problem of just being the same damned picture over and over.

As always, the usual caveats about the blurriness of lines between subject, rendering, and idea apply here.

Saturday, February 8, 2014

Taking Bad Pictures

It is part of the received wisdom in photography that one must take a lot of bad pictures.

Cartier-Bresson is frequently quoted as saying that your first 10,000 pictures are your worst. What is left out is that your first 100 and your first million are also your worst, taken as a whole. Generally, we get better over time.

Another oft-quoted truism is that it takes 10,000 hours to get good at something, anything. This is, of course, completely idiotic. It probably takes 10,000 hours of work to become proficient, in some sense, at flying an airplane or playing the piano. It does not take 10,000 hours to learn to fry an egg. I can get you frying eggs exceedingly well in an hour, if you're more or less attentive. Photography is slightly more complex than frying an egg, but much much easier than flying an airplane.

If photography were hard, there wouldn't be nearly as many people doing it. Yes, yes, most of them are awful. There are still huge numbers of truly excellent photographers out there. It's basically pretty easy to do pretty well, for pretty much any definition of pretty well.

These sorts of things bolster a culture of photography wherein one must take a lot of crummy pictures "first".

In reality, doing anything badly is the best possible way to ensure that you never do it well. A piano student is given accessible pieces to play, and urged to play them as slowly as necessary to play them first correctly, and then well. Of course the student would have trouble with the trickier Chopin, which is why the trickier Chopin is reserved for later in the process. Music teachers are at some pains to tell students not to practice mistakes, not to practice bad playing. Practice good playing, practice with focus, and only when you can focus, and only things that are within your grasp. Attempting pieces that are far beyond your grasp teaches you nothing, at best stalls your education in its tracks, and at worst teaches you a lot of bad habits which must be unlearned.

The admonition to carry your camera with you, always, and to shoot, shoot, shoot, is all about practicing bad picture taking. Are you a terrible pianist? Well, just be sure to spend 6 hours a day hammering randomly on the keys, 7 days a week, until you get awesome! Pick a piece of music, any piece, and smash your head against it endlessly!

It simply doesn't work that way. Even the neophyte should try to take good pictures. Simple ones, perhaps copies of other people's simple but good pictures. Don't just charge into the world clicking away at everything that looks cool. I certainly tried to learn to take good pictures by shoot, shoot, shooting. I'm still mad about it. The sculptor is not urged to carry a slab of marble everywhere, the painter does not carry paints everywhere, or even a sketchbook. Only the photographer is urged to Always Have The Camera.

If photography were a musical instrument, how would you practice your instrument today?

Instead of carrying your camera everywhere today, do that.

Friday, February 7, 2014

Blog Notes

My email address is: amolitor at molitor-design dot com

To follow this blog, you need to be able to log in the blogger.com, or google, or something. Anyways, go to www.blogger.com and if you see a "Dashboard" you're in the right place. Look down, and you'll see "Reading List" and under that a button for "Add". Click that!

Workshops

The web is, it sometimes seems, simply littered with people offering workshops on photography.

I occasionally think to myself "I write an incredibly unpopular blog, I know some stuff about photography, should I do workshops?" and then I start mulling over what on earth I would say.

There's plenty of really smart knowledgeable folks out there doing technical workshops. You wanna know how to light people? There's probably 100 people out there offering really excellent workshops. Also probably 1000 more offering terrible ones, but that's beside the point. The world is full of crap.

There's a whole bunch of dudes (why is it always dudes, anyways?) who will, ostensibly, teach you how to make pictures more or less like they shoot. These guys tend to produce flickr-ready landscapes or flickr-ready street photos. Technically solid, utterly derivative, very very popular on sharing sites with some equivalent to Trending Photos, and completely uninteresting to me. If you like that sort of thing, shop around, there's a lot to choose from.

I'm not a particular expert on anything technical, although I can generally muddle my way through the technical details of whatever to make a pretty good picture when technique is necessary. As a muddler, though, I probably shouldn't be teaching.

I'm haven't got any special skill in shooting exceedingly derivative 500px-ready photographs of any particular stripe. It's another thing I can muddle through, but usually only by accident, because frankly the whole thing skeeves me out entirely. I hate that crap. So, I probably shouldn't be teaching people how to do that either. Partly because I haven't got any special insight and partly because I'd end up screaming at the students.

The only things I can think of that I could legitimately do a workshop on is some sort of history of photography (after a bit of brushing up on the subject matter) or on the processes of inspiration.

And, to be honest, you can just look that stuff up, or read old posts on this blog. You'd have to be some kind of idiot to pay someone to teach you that stuff.

Beyond that I could probably yell at you to stop producing derivative garbage, to stop pixel peeping, to stop fucking around in photoshop.

Not sure there's a really big market for that, though. Maybe I should do a youtube video.