Thursday, April 6, 2017

A Question

Daniel Milnor, the eternal thorn in my side, has asked an interesting question on his blog.

Can someone shoot film and actually work full-time as a photographer?

I don't know any more than he does! But let's think about it a little, shall we?

Daniel notes that speed is of the essence, in many cases. So, eliminate those, obviously. You don't have to get too crazy, the turnaround on film isn't that terrible, but for stuff like spot news, film is probably out.

Assume that the target is digital, at some point. If it's going online, or into print, it's going to be digital eventually. The only place it's not is in fine art prints done in a darkroom, I think. Maybe there are a few shops still halftoning from slides, but I doubt it. So your product is getting scanned at some point.

Eliminate anything about the "distinctive look of film", then. If it's going digital eventually, it can be shot digitally and processed to match whatever look you want, including film looks (this is demonstrably true, I am starting to look around more closely and I suspect that quite a lot of the "film" we see online is in fact faked by people who are not as good at faking it as I am -- and I'm not that good.) This is probably true for fine art prints and other "pure analog" processes too, but we've already ditched those.

The reason, therefore, you're shooting film is because of the way it forces you, the photographer, to work. You might as well scan the negatives, then. Well, there's one corner case, I guess, where your process extends to prints which are then scanned. Call that an outlier. Maybe we'll look at it later.

The basic process, though, is going to be to shoot film, develop it, and scan negatives.

What is the downside here, for the client? Fewer frames to choose from, and a slightly slower turnaround. A few hours longer, which I cannot imagine is a deal killer for most work. If you're printing prints and scanning those, the turnaround goes up another hour or two. So what? Anyways, we're eliminated the small family of "speed is everything" gigs already. We're only looking at work where you can afford a day.

I think the elephant has to be the number of frames to choose from. Clients more or less have to be uncomfortable with the idea that they're not going to get the shot they need, if some jamoke is shooting film. If said jamoke is printing prints and scanning those, there will be even fewer shots to pick from because the jamoke ain't going to print every frame.

The trouble is, then, that the client doesn't want to the photographer to be a photo editor. Or, more exactly, shooting film is only going to work if you can gobble up the role of photo editor. The contract has to be to provide final pictures, or a very small set of final candidates to choose from. In these scenarios, the film delays become irrelevant. You're swapping photoshop time for developing time. If you're shooting film, you're being careful up front and doing less 'shopping in post, because, film. You're using a good make up artist instead of pissing away time on "frequency separation skin work" later, and so on.

Coincidentally, this is exactly how wedding photography works, which is why people can get away with shooting weddings on film.

So the trouble is, I think, really that the photographer isn't supposed to be doing the photo editing job as well in many cases. Photographers are expected to shoot a pile of frames, and then work with the client to select a broad sheaf of "possibles", then go back and retouch those, and finally help select finals out of that lot. The collaboration is supposed to take place "in post" rather than mid-shoot.

So, anyone shooting film has to be offering a kind of soup-to-nuts package, in which the client is more or less hands-off for a large part of the process. Big meeting up front to hammer out the requirements in detail, shot lists, whatever, then the client goes away. Big meeting at the end to pick out the finals out of the small collection of candidates.

What clients want to work that way these days?

Wednesday, April 5, 2017

Miksang

I have, on the recommendation of a nice chap who read something I wrote, recently read The Practice of Contemplative Photography, an approach to taking pictures that is rooted in some Buddhist ideas. Naturally, I found the idea appealing. The pictures, less so. Let us forge on.

The book begins, more or less, by pointing out that when we look at things in the world, there is a constant flood of internal chatter, of semiotics, of labelling and naming. We see a rose, and we name its color, we remind ourselves that grandmother grew roses and loved them, we muse that roses so frequently disappoint us with this scent, we move on to reminding ourselves that we need to buy a hoe before the spring gardening season. We might say something about "a rose by any other name" with our inside voice, and wonder who wrote that, and so on.

We might even photograph the thing.

The camera would then dutifully record the intensity and color of light bouncing off the various parts of the rose, but nothing about scent, grandma, or poetry. The resulting picture might, therefore, disappoint us. Well, there are many reasons we might find ourselves disappointed, but the literalness of the camera as compared with the depth of our personal experience of the rose is certainly a potential source of strife.

So far, so good. The book is On Track at this point. Then the wheels fall off.

The solution, the authors suppose, is to learn to see what is truly there, and only what is truly there, and to photograph that. This strikes me as akin to saying that my pie crusts are never very flaky, I guess I will eat only oatmeal forever.

In truth, what photography as an art concerns itself is precisely this problem. The game is to record the color and intensity of light in such as way that the viewer will tend to put that cloud of semiotics, of muttering, of memory, of meaning, back on to the photograph. While it is true that the literalness of the photo creates a narrow channel through which to shove our thoughts, a narrow and unreliable one, this is in fact what the job is. It is not to give up.

Well, that said, there is something to be said for a really well made bowl of oatmeal, and this book does provide some genuinely useful guidance on that front, as well as I think potentially laying groundwork.

The book gives us a method, and a set of exercises which expand on the method and which help to elucidate the method. I will briefly sketch the method, probably inaccurately, but perhaps you will get the idea. Then I will discuss, a little.

As we pass through the world, as noted we look and see things constantly, covering them over with that internal monologue of memories, side chatter, and so on. Every now and then, we notice something which stops us, for just a moment. A flash of color, a coincidence of light, a shape. Just for an instant, the internal monologue has nothing to say, and then it picks up again. If we're "out shooting" we might snatch up our camera and start hunting around for the shot, while the internal monologue blathers on about whatever it was we noticed,

The book suggests that at those moments, rather than clawing for the camera, rather than letting the internal chatter start talking about whatever we noticed, that instead we pause, that we quiet the inside voice, and that we simply look. As non-verbally as possible, without moving, visually investigate the sight. Work out just what it is that we saw, the limits of the perception. What is its character, where are its edges, and so on. Then, quietly, without starting up the inside voice, reach for the camera and photograph what we saw.

The conceit here is "pure seeing", the resulting photographs have no explicit meaning. They are fresh and new.

While there is no doubt that there is a certain freshness and beauty to the resulting pictures, there is no doubt that they are without meaning, and leave little room for the viewer to impose meaning. They all look roughly the same, for what I think are obvious reasons: What we perceive in an instant is very very small. Our larger view of our surroundings is built up largely of memory and intuition, our eyes simply don't see very much at one time. We see a single object, or a grouping that we accept as a singleton, or, sometimes, the relationship between two such. A row of bottles opposite the pumpkin is about as complicated a single perception is going to be.

It is in fact the internal chatter (or some portion of it), suppressed in this method, that builds the richer, wider, visual experience that we enjoy.

The results, therefore, embody a sort of obvious, vaguely asian, minimalism. One suspects the authors (and their acolytes) of staging many of their shots, so clean and beautiful are the results. I myself have shot lots of this sort of thing, not by using the methods outlined in the book.



So, what's good about it?

Well, the methods they talk about work. You can in fact learn something real about "pure seeing" from this book, you can learn to do it. The exercises are helpful, and you can learn to see in this particular way. I cannot see any harm in learning to better see what is actually there, clear of all the mental clutter.

I suspect that the methods are best used as foundation material, rather than as a final process. I envision, in a sort of vague way, a process of pure seeing as a one of several tools to visually investigate an object, a scene, an archetype, prior to working out how to shoot it. I espouse, without ambiguity, the opposite idea in the final result -- namely that it should be rife with meaning, that it should drive the viewer to new heights of internal chatter. But, perhaps, by first seeing what is truly there without the chatter, we can build a better picture in the end.

This strikes me as more essentially Buddhist anyways. The Buddhist does not strive to live in the moment, to see and feel and exist in the here and now only for the purpose of doing that, but for the purpose of living more fully, more joyfully, more richly. The ideas that westerners seem drawn to are tools to an end, not just an excuse to get incredibly high and mumble incomprehensiblities at one another.

As a final note, the authors cite some work by their inspiration, Chögyam Trungpa, which doesn't actually look that much like their work. This Tibetan guy was taking substantially richer pictures. I see that on miksang,com they've selected a smaller group of his pictures which do look like their somewhat boring minimalist exercises. They're learning. And they are monetizing the shit out of it.

Saturday, April 1, 2017

Take Heart!

It's not going to be All Hasselblad All The Time (although my traffic has blown up around the topic, good god, it's ridiculous).

I'm working my way through a couple of books. Google "Miksang" if you want a preview. It's interesting, and I will have some things to say about it. Hat tip to one John Wilson for the pointer. Also coming up, some detailed commentary on Vivian Maier! My library has acquired a couple of the monographs, which I am spending time with. I don't think my opinion has changed much, but I do need to spend more time and all things are possible. Either way I will have more to say.

So, hang on, gentle reader, hang on!

A Crazy Rumor!

I do not buy this rumor. My theories are well documented, and this isn't one of them. Still, it occurred to me, and it does fit the timelines nicely.

If you are married to the idea that Perry Oosting was forced out of Hasselblad, but lack a reason for it, here's one you can use.

Late December 2016, Perry Oosting closes the deal to get money from DJI, placing a couple DJI guys on Hasselblad's board.

At the first real board meeting with the new board, mid-January some time, the new guys push to cement the relationship with Hasselblad Ambassador Ming Thein by hiring him to the executive staff. Oosting balks, "no way", for whatever reason. DJI guys demand it, and either Oosting is fired, or quits in a huff.

New CEO duly installed, takes office on or around Feb 1. In fairly short order the relevant negotions, background checks, and so on happen. 8 weeks later, Mr. Thein joins the executive team, under the new, more pliant, CEO.

Another Comparison Opportunity

Hasselblad and Fuji have helpfully built for us practically the same camera at the same time, which can provide us some insights into Hasselblad's business.

The Fuji weighs slightly more than the Hasselblad (825 vs. 725 grams) and is about half an inch deeper. The Fuji has better specifications in literally every single dimension than I can identify except for flash sync speed. The bill-of-materials cost of these two cameras is clearly within a few hundred bucks, with the Fuji almost certainly more expensive since it has better displays and a focal plane shutter.

The Hasselblad is about $9000 versus the Fuji's $6500. Ouch. That's a $2500 cliff to climb on the basis of not very much.

I see people saying "I am a professional, and I need the higher flash sync speed to OVERPOWER THE SUN" which is utter nonsense. Actual professionals know how to deal with that, and they know they can buy a whole bunch of scrims and a whole bunch of stands for $2500. And then you've got scrims and stands which could maybe be handy in other places. The reason this is trotted out is because that is literally the only specification in which the 'blad wins.

Then we see the guys saying that they held both and one was "like a Ferrari" while the other was "like a Ford Pinto" which made me laugh a lot. Unless you can actually unpack that a little bit, all you're saying is "I really wanted to own the expensive one" but nobody seems to be able to unpack it. There's some blather about haptics that usually shows up here, but that's just another coded way of saying "I really wanted to own the expensive one."

(The Ferrari comparison is especially hilarious, Ferraris are notorious for being fast maintenance nightmares, in addition to being ridiculously exclusive. One buys a Ferrari not because one wants a good car or even a fast car, one buys a Ferrari because one wants a Ferrari. In fact, Ferrari will not sell you a new car unless you have proved that you're a Ferrari Lover by owning second-hand cars for a while.)

To be sure, there is absolutely no doubt that the Hasselblad feels better in the hands. No question about it. Where that feeling comes from is tricky to comb out, though. Probably H did indeed pay a lot of attention to "haptics" but I'm pretty sure Fuji didn't just wing it. They've built a few cameras in their time, and have a reputation for building gear that fits well in the hand. Even if we grant that H did a better job, there is no doubt that the reputation and price tag play a role in how it feels in the hand. How much would require $15,500 woth of cameras, a 100 gram weight, and a very carefully designed double-blind study, and I'm not seeing that happening any time soon.

Ok, so what's going on here? It's not just that Hasselblad is laughing merrily and pocketing an additional $2500 per camera. In the first place, the retailer is pocketing a good slice of that. In the second place, Hasselblad's manufacturing costs are undoubtedly higher, as well as all the fixed costs. Every X1D sold has to contribute fistful of dollars to the CEO's salary (and everyone else's), the Fuji has to pay a much smaller tax because Fuji is a giant company shipping huge amounts of product of various sorts. The tax for salaries, marketing, service, and so on, are all far more spread out.

Still, how much it costs to make it is irrelevant to the user. The user is interested in how much value can be obtained for the dollar, and in the case of Hasselblad it is clear that the value has almost nothing to do with the actual capabilities of the camera. There is just no way you are not buying less camera for more money.

It's the nameplate, the reputation, that really gets them the $2500 pop.

There is nothing wrong with this. Photography is, for most of us (and for virtually everyone who will buy either of these two devices) a hobby. For these clients it is an absurdly expensive hobby. These people have disposable income, and they're spending it on things they love and want to possess. The differences between "I wish to own a Hasselblad," "I wish to own a nice camera," and "I will have the filet mignon" are extremely small, varying mainly in dollar amounts. All are indulgences which make the buyer happy.

So, understand this: Hasselblad isn't competing on specifications. They are not offering you more camera for more money. They are offering a Hasselblad for more money.

Now that they have clarified their marketing plan, we can pretty much predict that there will be a laser focus of delivering definitively Hasselblad cameras to aficionados, and on enlarging that base of aficionados. The specs will be fine, there will be a lot of megapickles around. There will be a credible effort to stay more or less even, feature-wise, with the market. Beyond that, though, the effort will be to ensure that everyone knows that Hasselblad is the ultimate photography machine.

Well, everyone in China, anyways.

Thursday, March 30, 2017

Hasselblad's Long, Strange, Trip

We have H in the news again, in a small way, and no doubt all three of my readers are wondering when I am going to weigh in. The latest news, in a bizarre twist, almost literally marries two of my favorite topics for gossip and speculation, about which more in a moment.

A little back story. I have been beating the same little drum for a while now, to wit, that H hired Perry Oosting to investigate whether Hasselblad could position itself as a luxury brand. I offer three bits of evidence for this, which you may find slender or no. 1) Oosting's history with luxury brands, 2) The apparently not very successful Hasselblad "snap on" camera for the apparently mildly successful Lenovo Moto Z phone and 3) The X1D camera which seems to be finding success, but perhaps with a different demographic than expected or hoped for?

Recall one of my other little drums: There are people who just want pictures, and there are people who like cameras. There are also people who like photographs and photography. These groups overlap to a degree, but the markets should be treated differently. The people who just want pictures use their phones, period, full stop.

My theory is that what Oosting was looking in to was whether Hasselblad could penetrate the market of extremely wealthy people who Just Want Pictures, and that he discovered that the answer was "No."

In the process, H built this X1D camera which was an unexpected success. My theory continues that Hasselblad did a little digging and found that there was a pretty good sized market, still, people who like cameras and who also have more money than sense. The last bit of my theory is that they discovered that many of these people live in China, or nearby. My guess is that they discovered that they had a lot of orders for the X1D from the Pacific Rim, and that some further investigation discovered that it was not (alas) wealthy oligarchs who just wanted pictures, but rather wealthy dopes who like cameras.

Perry Oosting then pivoted and told his Board of Directors that Hasselblad did indeed need to return to its roots, which have always been extracting money from the well heeled camera lover. There is no billion dollar play putting a H branded widget in every trophy bride's purse, but there are still plenty of well heeled gearheads out there.

Note, though, that the official story since Oosting's hire was always a return to the roots, so it's possible that my "luxury play" side trip is entirely my fantasy, and what we're seeing it actually H staying the course, returning to their roots, since the day they hired Oosting.

Back to my fantastical tale spinning. The deal with DJI then serves two purposes, the first being of course money, the second being to place a couple of wealthy chinese gearheads on the Board of Hasselblad.

The next move was to hire the patron saint of gearheads, a guy who shows no evidence of even liking photography very much but who adores cameras, as the "Chief of Strategy". Yep. Ming Thein works for Hasselblad now, in this vaguely defined role.

Why? Well, there are many possible reasons. Ming's vast knowledge of business is not among them, H being owned by a private equity firm (such firms are, literally, in the business of supplying business acumen to beleaguered firms). Ming's vast knowledge of camera user experience is likewise not a likely reason. In the first place he's at least as idiosyncratic as the average camera user, and in the second place you can simply buy or rent that skill from any number of sources. No reason to hire the guy as a Chief Anything.

No, they want him for his perceived influence. The other bits and pieces are better than a poke in the eye; not having to explain "P&L" might save a little time one day, and I'm sure Ming will have many suggestions for the engineers (which they will, mostly, ignore - I know how engineers operate). While perhaps handy, these are not the underlying reasons for making Ming a Chief Something or Other.

Mostly, they want a gearhead's gearhead pushing their name out there, pushing the idea that the 100 megapickle sensor is simply the shiznit, and so on. It is also possible that H sees an advantage in hiring an Asian here. The politics of ethnicity on the Pacific Rim are not a swamp I would ever choose to wade in to, largely because I have no idea beyond "it's extremely fraught". Still, it's possible that from Sweden it looked like a good idea, and for all I know, it is an excellent one.

H is hiring a senior mechanical design engineer in Sweden, and a project manager (no location given), right now. This means they have plenty of projects in the pipeline, and are looking to ramp up capacity on the design side. Interestingly, both jobs require English fluency, but not Swedish.

My guess is that they've got a 100 megapickle X1D-like object in the works, and that Mr. Thein will be at some pains to explain to us all why it is, really, the only camera that a truly discerning artist can possibly use. Well, I mean, obviously if your standards and skills are not at the Very Highest Level you don't need it. But for the few, the exalted, the X2D-100c wunderkamera is the only thing that will really suit.

Ming has done a truly masterful job, in hindsight, of using the "look, it's not the camera, it's the photographer" theme, and twisting it slightly, to make absurdly expensive gear look like a must have but only for the truly elite which is just a goddamned piece of marketing wizardry. He's turned a truly egalitarian idea literally on its head to sell Veblen goods. Hat's off to Ming! Huzzah!

Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Book Teardown #2

The victim. Another free book from the library. I checked more carefully this time to be more sure that it was a standard sewn binding in a standard case. It turned out to be just what it appeared.


Backed spine. 10 quires, the quires are visible as little "lumps" along the top edge of the block of pages inside the case. Each quire also has visible a very slight "gap" at its center, indicating where the gathering of sheets is folded.

You might think of a quire as a sort of comic book or pamphlet, of "sheets" which are laid atop one another (8 sheets in the case of this book) and then folded, to create (in this case) 16 leaves, or 32 pages. The book is 320 pages long, plus one tipped in plate which we will see later on.


Opening it up at the middle of a quire, we've going to find the stitching, to verify that we're looking at a sewn binding.



Here is the stitching. Note the black thread in the middle, yellow/plain linen elsewhere, which gives us a clue as to the details of the sewing. Evidently each "stitch" is sewn separately, in this sewing pattern. Again, we'll see a little more on this later. There are many patterns for sewing, however. When hand sewing, I usually use a single piece of thread for the entire binding, so you'd never see this sort of color change.


For comparison, this is what pages look like that are NOT the middle of a quire. No stitching visible! The outer pages of quires, where one quire meets the next, look slightly, subtly, different again. We''ll see this shortly.


Beginning the teardown, we'll cope with endpapers first. Here is the endpaper tipped on to the last page of the book. You can see the narrow band where the endpaper is glued to the outer page of the outermost quire.


We tear the tipped-in surface off, separating the text block, and then the endpaper is free for another 1/4 inch or so at the hinge, and then we peel it up from the pastedown a little. I am pretending that I want to preserve the endpapers here. Note the cheesecloth/mesh material of the mull now becoming visible.

Recall that the mull is glued to the spine of the text block, and then to the case. We can see here where the mull crosses the hinge area from text block to case.


Both endpapers de-tipped and peeled back, pastedowns area slightly lifted. If we wanted to rebuild the text block, replace the mull, and glue it back into the case (a reasonable thing to want to do, often) we'd need to lift more of the pastedown to expose more area on the case for regluing the new mull. This will do for illustration, however.


I'm just going to cut the mull to free the text block. 


Text block freed, end papers more or less intact on the case. If i were to do the rebuild described above, I would lift the endpapers further without the text block in the way, and clean up the leftover mull glued onto the case to create a fresh area to glue new mull on to.

Preserving endpapers is a gigantic pain in the ass.

If you inscribe a book to someone, never, ever, write on the endpapers. You never know, the book might be important to someone, and they might want it repaired. The endpapers might not survive the repair, and your inscription would be lost.

Leaf in a page or two before you inscribe. Please!


Spine of the text block. Note spine inlay material, the brown paper. The method here is to build a laminate of paper and glue, over the mull, to create the right degree of stiffness in the spine. You want the spine to curve gently when the book is fully open, rather than bending and concentrating stress along a single line. The spine inlay also protects the case and the text block from one another, allowing them to move freely against one another without abrasion.


Spine inlay scraped off to reveal the mull. Stitching thread becomes visible, see the black lines across the spine? That's the black thread we saw inside the quire, at the center. We can roughly guess how the stitching works now.

Scraping/peeling the paper off with a knife up to this point. Next up, we'll use coarse sandpaper.


Another view of the mull, at the same stage of disassembly as above.


Sanded down to clean up, we're down to mull+glue at this point, and we're beginning to abrade the mull. There is very little stiffness left in the spine. The stitching is still intact under the mull.


Let's start taking the text block apart. We'll cut the quires one from the other, which will cut the stitching as we go.

The stitching serves two functions. The first is to "staple" the quires together in the sense that, say, a comic book or saddle-stapled pamphlet it stapled. The nested stack of pages is held together at the fold by the thread (and, as we shall see, sometimes a little glue). The stitching also connects each quire to its neighbors, however. So, cutting the quires apart cuts the threads and will, generally, have a side effect of disassembling the stacked pages of the quire. We'll see this shortly.

Since after sewing the spine of the text block is painted with glue, we get a little seepage of glue between the quires, which effectively "tips" the outer pages of neighboring quires together. Also, a little glue can seep through the thread holes (see below).

Find the gap between two quires, by counting pages carefully, and watching out for tipped in plates! Check and double-check. Look at the spine from above, and so on. Note the glue seepage that has "tipped" one quire to the next. It looks subtly different from the way pages within a quire open.


Peel the quires apart, much as we did the endpapers from the text block. Gently pressing and working the two glued faces apart. The can damage the outer sheet of the quire, but that's an easy repair, so let us not panic overmuch.


Peeling further to expose the mull, view from inside the book, we've separated the quires at this point and what's holding them together now is the glued-on mull material, and the stitching. We have fully "broken" the spine of the book at this point -- you may have noticed this happening through normal wear and tear in an older book. The cheesecloth of the mull is visible, if you peer closely.


We cut the quire off now, slicing the mull and quire-to-quire stitcthing. The quire, a separate 32 page booklet now, gets separated entirely. The stitching got cut, which will release the thread from its "stapling" duties to a degree.


Open the quire to the middle page, here is the stitching we noticed in the intact book, well above. It's starting to pop loose and can be (gently) pulled up and out.


Removed stitching, a clean spine. The quire still hangs together due to glue seepage through the thread holes and also, I think, the way the holes were punched.


Pulling the sheets of the quire apart. Note glue seepage through stitching holes, requiring a careful touch. Innermost sheet first, careful at the stitching holes, them gently apart to give the paper time to gently de-laminate and leave a glued face behind. Again., if you damage a sheet at this point, it's not a big deal, this is an easy repair.


The disassembled quire. 32 pages, 16 "leaves", 8 sheets of folded paper.



Note the plate tipped into the quire. This can throw your page counting off if you are careless. Check and double-check when identifying the ends of a quire! (the center has stitching and is easy to prove, the ends are a little more subtle). This quire appeared to have 17 leaves on one side, and 16 on the other.


Damaged outermost sheet of the quire, I did not do a very good job here. Also, if you get aggressive cleaning up the spine with sandpaper, damage may accrue here. This would need a repair (rice paper tape on the spine, re-punch stiching holes, very easy to do, and largely invisible once the book is rebuilt) if we were going to re-sew this.


And that's it! I could repeat the process with all the other quires, lift the pastedowns on the covers a bit more, and then I could re-sew the text block, rebuild the spine (new mull, new spine inlay) and glue the whole thing back into the case, and then re-glue the endpapers.