There's a guy who shall remain nameless who is more or less notorious on a segment of social
media for posting cute little "prompts for discussion" along with occasional photos from
20th century photographers, and relentless requests to sign up for whatever his latest stupid
thing is where he will do the same thing.
It's the prompts that get me. Two recent ones are these:
Do we take a photograph or make it?
If a shadow selfie a portrait?
These are, I hope it is obvious, dumb questions. But why? Well, at least one of them
is exhausted, but that's not it.
They are dumb because they are not questions about photography or photographs at all, but
rather questions about words. Nobody who takes photographs is at all mystified by the
process they use to take pictures. They know how their photographs come to be, in some detail.
The question of make vs. take is what word you use to summarize the well
understood process, not a question about the nature of the process.
Ditto shadow-selfies. Everyone knows what they are. You photograph your own shadow. That's
it. Is it a portrait? That is a question about the meaning of the word portrait
not a question about the nature of the shadow-selfie.
You could argue, perhaps, that by asking about the word we are asking about how we think about these
photographs and photographic processes, how do we make sense of these objects for ourselves?
Well, ok, maybe, but then why not ask that instead? Asking it in the form of a glib prompt yields
a whole spectrum of answers, ranging from "yes" to "no," and that's about it.
My point here is that I suspect a lot of what we think of as "philosophical questions about
photography" is in fact just glib blathering about words. The underlying acts and objects are,
in context, well understood so perhaps it appears that all that's left to discuss if what language
we use to describe it (see also the ongoing "shoot" discourse.)
I claim that there are actually things we don't understand about the underlying objects and processes
and that we might could talk about those. People are, as a rule, not fans. Some take the position
that these things are not well suited to word-based analysis, but mostly people are just shy of
tackling these things.
I'm a guy who arguably uses more words than practically anybody, and arguably way too many, to
talk about photography and photographs. I like to think that I'm actually talking and thinking
about the underlying nature of the objects and processes, though, and not just stupid language
chopping.
It's depressingly common for artists to do a bunch of shit, and then someone rolls up
and says "oh yeah, some guy name Julio in Buenos Aires did that in 1997" and then
the artist has to find something new to do. At least, this is the default.
You can wrestle around with your conscience and wonder if you're doing a new variation
on Julio's thing, or whatever, but the basic understanding is that It Has Been Done and
you'll go down as a mere copycat. There is an underlying assumption here, which is false:
that assumption is that everything is done, essentially, on a global stage. Everything
must be measured against the global stage.
The fact is that the people who live on my block have never heard of Julio or his work.
It may even be that very few people have heard of Julio or his work, but in the Grand
Tradition of Art none of this matters. It's been done. You will be revealed at a
mere copier of Julio, and that's that. The people on my block will never get to see
work of this kind, if we follow this to its logical conclusion. They'll never see
Julio's work, because maybe Julio is in the end a pretty minor artist. They'll never
see anyone else's either, because nobody wants to copy Julio.
This is deeply stupid.
The very idea of the global stage is fairly stupid. Yes, it's where the money mostly
is, 60 billion dollars a year, spread across 3 million people, so everyone's also waiting
tables in their spare time. The global stage sucks, everyone is starving, the art isn't
really much better, and it's stifling local art because "Julio already did that."
Just make whatever. Honestly, go look Julio up and outright steal his shit. Who cares?
Julio might, I suppose, but if so he's dumb. It's not like you're taking anything
away from Julio, or that you're making any money in the first place. If you feel bad
about it, reference Julio. "Inspired by Buenos Aires artist Julio, you can see his
work <here>" or whatever.
Everyone on your block gets to see the cool, or meaningful, or beautiful, thing that
Julio invented and that you rediscovered. Nobody loses anything. The world is, in a small
way, better for it.
I made more stuff for Halloween, and set it out in a local park for people to enjoy, which I guess some did.
We (by which I mean mostly me, but other people are semi-interested) are trying to make it a Thing to do up
the local small disused park for Halloween. This is what I made.
The arch is about 7-8 feet high in the center, the skulls and demon masks are life sized (the masks are actually
my face.) There's electronics behind each skull. One is a disassembled flashy-light spooky-sound-effects thing that
was playing through the red horn visible between the leftmost and center skull. You can see the flashy light as
well, the silvery rectangle below the leftmost skull.
The center skull played bad piano music, alternating
nursery rhymes played badly, "spooky" music, and occasionally Rick Astley, all in bangy piano clips
played through the black horn below and slightly right of the center skull, from the guts of a very cheap
toy electronic piano. The center skull had red LEDs in its eye sockets that pulsed along to the music.
Here it is on the bench, illustrating its awesomeness.
The rightmost skull just had some fairy lights that were wound around the hand on top of the arch.
The effect, standing under it, was somewhat cacaphonic. Overwhelming might be pushing it, but definitely
A Lot.
Note, please, the masses of tiny homonculi climbing to be eaten by the rightmost demon. Thank you.
This skull is about 4 feet tall, 3 feet wide.
The eyes light up and flash and wink and whatnot in an absurdly complex pattern that took far too long to write the software
for.
I consider it possible I went a little overboard. It was pretty fun though.
A constant source of irritation for me, and one that I absolutely should not let bother
me even slightly, is the influence of popularity on photography.
There's a lot of creative things to do out there, and virtually all of them require a
lot more commitment than photography. Do you want to be a poet? A novelist? A painter?
An architect? Well, bad news, bub, you're going to have to go deep and work hard and you
might still never get any good at it. But let me tell you about photography!
Photography is easy. It always has been, but at this point it's frankly absurd. Literally
anyone can become a competent photographer, without even working particularly hard. Almost
literally anyone can learn to bang out competent and attractive examples of any number
of genres. Flower pictures? Portraits? Landscapes? Street? Yes to all of those. Sure, you
might never be brilliant, but only weirdo critics can tell the difference between
competent and excellent and, quite frankly, they're probably just making shit up.
The result of this is that virtually everyone who styles themself something of a photographer
is thoroughly unserious about photography itself.
This rankles, but it ought not. There's genuinely no harm here. Everyone should go nuts.
This is in contrast to something like poetry. Among those who are remotely competent poets,
many or most are obsessive about something in it. They might have a deep obsession with
the history of the Lake poets, or they might really like something to do with partial
rhyming, or whatever. The point is that a lot of poets are kind of weirdos about something
poetic, and as a consequence they're pretty sympatico with other poetry weirdos. This is
true even if the obsessions don't overlap.
Not so, photography. Virtually every photographer is a dilettante, and not obsessive at
all about anything photographic. They quite naturally find the occasional obsessive to
be weird and off-putting. They even tend to find the obsessives to be judgmental, sometimes
because the obsessives can be pretty judgmental, but not always. When someone else is
vigorously doing a thing differently than you do, it can feel like a judgement even
when no such thing is intended.
The result of this is that most photography "content" in this modern era is aimed at the
unserious, is aimed to read as non-judgmental.
The result is endless miles of incredibly anodyne, repetitive, essentially stupid material.
The writing is a mix of industry news and "here's an old picture!" with occasional "here's
a really boring but very pretty picture!"
As an obsessive, I hate this stuff. I am interested in my own weirdo niche obsessions, and
secondarily I am interested in other people's weirdo obsessions. Very much in last place, I
am interested in yet another round of "look, it's Diane Arbus' photo of twins, again, paired,
again, with some stupid quote from Szarkowski!"
This, however, sells very very well indeed to the dilettantes. Much as I want everyone to
love my weirdo obsessions, it all just feels like judgements to most photographers.
I got into a small discussion with a dude on twitter, in which it developed that I didn't
actually have much of a point. He was remarking that Hannah Arendt identified the use
of cliché as a marker of not-much-thought, with sometimes consequences.
Upon further thought, this meshes fairly neatly with a number of things I've been thinking
of over the last few years. My belief is that humans husband their cognitive resources fairly
jealously, and increasingly so in these over-mediated times. We simply refuse to expend
actual thought on a lot of stuff, and have developed a lot of strategies to simplify
those parts of our lives which we think of as "thoughtful." Specifically, we seek to simplify the process of reading, both literally and as a metaphor for consuming broader media. This is a generalization, I think,
of Arendt's ideas around the use of cliché.
This shows up most obviously in literal reading, especially reading longer pieces of writing.
If you pay much attention, you realize pretty fast that people don't read. Not actually.
What they usually do is skim, they look for keywords, they look for phrases, they look
for a variety of clues. The purpose of the clue-finding is to help fit the text into a frame.
The goal is to identify what the text probably says by matching it to a pretty small set
of templates. If it's about color science in Sony cameras, it's probably either "Sony is
awesome" or "Sony sucks" so all we have to do is work out which one it is and we're done.
Surprisingly, people will do this same thing with a 30 word tweet. Rather than reading it,
they'll pattern match it to a canned position, and assume it's a re-iteration of that
position. A repetition, if you will, of the cliché.
This has a consequence that turns up in the way we write or more generally "produce content."
At some level, we know that people are doing this, so we write in such a way as to ease
the pattern matching. First, we adopt a well-established position that we're simply
going to re-iterate, and then we lard the piece up with the right keywords and phrases to allow the casual reader to easily identify the position we're re-iterating.
This is, essentially, to deploy cliché as a communication device. The New Yorker will never
challenge you, you can rely on it to perfectly meet your expectations, because it traffics in what we might broadly construe as clichés.
On both the production and consumption side, we're communicating in tropes and clichés,
simply staking out the same positions over and over, saying the same things over and
over. To be fair, original thoughts have always been rare and the bulk of human interaction
has always been repetitive and shallow. It is possible that the glut of modern media has
made this worse, though, as we more and more jealously guard our limited cognitive energy.
The principle in play here I have named the Least Cognitive Effort Principle. The LCE principle.
For the most part, movies and novels run on rails. We know how the superhero film is
going to end up, the only variations are in which special effects will be deployed when and,
honestly, that's not super important. Go ahead, take a pee break. The movie matches the
template it telegraphed in the trailer and the first 2 minutes, it's fine. You know
this film. You know this novel about the young woman in Brooklyn writing her first
book, you can pretty much dip in anywhere. Everything is anodyne and predictable, because unless it is
nobody will even pretend to read it, watch it, listen to it. We're
too overloaded. There's a guy on twitter who just started a photo newsletter, got 20,000 subscribers out of the gate, and the first three newsletters have been the most uninteresting, anodyne, drivel ever.
People love it.
As I have mentioned repeatedly in the past, we see this with photographs.
News photographs do not function to show us what is new about the event, but rather what
is the same. The photograph reveals the event to be exactly like the other similar events,
we can pattern-match easily. Lefty protest. Righty protest. House fire. Politician speech
(right/left.) Etc. We identify the photo immediately, and react not to the picture but
to the template we've matched it to.
This makes people like me weirdos. I actually like expending brainpower on a photo, it's my
hobby. This makes my understanding, my reading, of a photo different from that of some
normie. I'm noticing the details that make it different, they're noticing only the large
structure that makes it the same. They're identifying the underlying cliché.
Recall my Theory Of Photographs which is: that they constitute in a
sense a portal to "there," that you react in a sense as if you were "there," and that
you imagine a world to contain the photo. You imagine the time before and after
the shutter press, you imagine the stuff just out of frame, and so on. You do
this as an almost biological reaction to the hyper-detailed semi-reality of the photo.
The LCE principle implies a refinement: that you do all this imagining according to the LCE
principle. You tend to imagine the world around the photo as pretty similar to yours,
you ascribe motivations to the people in the photo in the cognitively-cheapest way
possible. You're much more likely to imagine the policeman's emotions as matching whatever
cheap opinion you have of cops than you are to actually inspect the cop's body language
and expression. You'll react and imagine in response to large, easily identified, features
of the picture, and you'll react and imagine as cheaply as possible.
Thinking is hard, and generally people try to avoid it. We speak, listen, read, and write
in clichés and near-clichés, as much as possible.
Something I have noticed and mentioned in the past is this idea of the "semiotically rich" photograph (or whatever, to be honest, it needn't be a photo.) What I mean is an object that seems to be loaded up with some sort of symbolic content, it's trying to mean something. It might or might not succeed in that goal.
Imagine, if you will, a photo of a beautiful flower lying on a wooden board, a still life. It's not trying very hard to mean anything, and it probably doesn't mean much of anything. It's pretty, and that's nice.
Now slice the flower cleanly across the blossom with a sharp knife. One clean stroke. Photograph that. You might even leave the knife in frame.
This photo is trying to mean something. There's the flower, beautiful and innocent, and it's been sundered! The blade gleams wickedly in the
background. Good heavens! But what does it mean? Probably nothing, at least if it's shown to you without any specific context. This is what I
have called a semiotically rich photo, it is freighted with meaning but doesn't actually explain itself at all. It is an enigma,
fundamentally.
Now replace the flower with a crucifix, similarly hacked in two.
At this point the picture begins to explain itself, at least a little. A symbol for Christianity is chopped in two, surely this is
some sort of comment on religion, or religiosity. We don't exactly have chapter and verse here, there remains a degree of enigma, but
some sort of meaning is revealed here. The photo is semiotically rich and it also reveals itself.
I propose that there are in some useful sense two axes upon which a photo (or other art) can be placed. One is, roughly, how hard the
object is trying to mean, and the other is how successfully it actually does mean. This suggests, of course, the photo
that doesn't try very hard to mean, but which nevertheless carries a crystal clear message of some sort. I'm wrestling with that. Not
sure it's a thing, and of course if it isn't, the model rather collapses.
This is mostly of note to me because it occurs to me that quite a bit of contemporary art is trying very hard to mean, but does not
actually explain itself. You can see that the thing is semiotically rich, it's intensely trying to convey something, but what it's
conveying is completely opaque. The little title card next to it will make all clear.
The sundered flower is, according to the title card, a symbol of lost youth, cut apart by age and yet still beautiful in a way.
Tomorrow, the flower might be a symbol for femininity, the knife a metaphor for rape.
The rich but empty artwork is remarkably flexible. The explanation usually can't be just any fool thing, it had to fit with the
art, but there is some degree of flex here. If there isn't much flexibility, then more or less by definition the art is explaining
itself, defying your efforts to explain it as something else. The art means all by itself without any help.
I have to say I don't much like rich-but-empty art very much, it feels like a bit of a cheat.
The book I'm going to talk about here is a book you can't buy. It was a self-pub one-shot, in 2020. Full disclosure, when he was doing the book Tim generously
allowed me a look at a pre-print PDF and I gave him some notes and a blurb. Honestly, the book was excellent before I
looked at it. I have never checked to see which, if any, of my notes he took. He used my blurb, though, which was very
flattering.
Tim is also busy dying now, and was supposed to die a month or so ago. He muffed it and apparently now has a few months
left, which he is using to blog fairly aggressively at his excellent Leicaphilia blog.
Since he got his brief reprieve, I felt that I should give him a chance to read my review of his book, which I then realized
I had to write. So, here we are.
Since you can't buy a copy of it, I made one of those flip-through videos, which will give you at least a sense of the
thing.
I like this book a great deal, I think it's an absolutely superb example of a particular form. It's not a form that I
am myself well-suited to doing, and it's a bit old school. It's a form that I like a lot, nevertheless.
What we have here is a book very much in the character of Evans' American Photographs or Frank's The Americans
and while I won't say this is better or worse than those, I think it can stand with them. They can go to the same parties.
It's a whole bunch of black and white photos, all taken from the windows of a car, over a couple of decades, with Leica
cameras. Not my jam at all in terms of making. There is grain a-plenty if you're into that. There's quite a bit
of car-window framing. The themes are all car-accessible: roadside sights, automotive stuff, roads, toll booths, other cars.
There are no photos from the remote wilderness, no photos looking up, or looking down, no photos of interiors.
What is there, then?
There's a hell of a lot of structure. It's bookended with abstraction: you segue into the body of the book with a series
of extremely spare rural road scenes, and exit the book with a fantastic disintegration into abstraction. In between, it's "Walker Evans" sequencing
in spades. Each photo connects to the next through some graphical element, or some subject matter. One photo contains has a sign with
a line drawing of a washer-dryer set, the next photo has an actual washer and dryer incongruously set outside. These photos are
drawn from a very deep archive.
Yet at the same time there is much more going on here. It's not just one and then the next one. There are repeated themes, mainly that
of small local religion, but also mass produced statuary, semi-rural decay, boarded up shopfronts, and so on. As often as not
the themes overlap, it's a boarded up shopfront church, it's a mass produced concrete statue of the Virgin Mary, and so on.
Not only is there a fairly robust linear structure, as in the two older books cited above, there is also a sonata-like
repetition of theme, a constant circling back to specific tropes.
The photos themselves are all at least good. There are very few absolute bangers. Everything lands somewhere between the
well-framed document of an at least mildly interesting subject, and the well-framed abstraction with only murkily discernible
subject. Mostly, the photos lean toward the former.
There are any number of excellent juxtapositions, including what I consider to be the finest pairing of photos I have
ever seen. At 2:05 in the video, the sign on the left quotes Proverbs, noting that one never knows what's going to happen
(and therefore, presumably, you should go to church or something) and the signs in the photo on the right first urge
you to pre-order Holiday Chicken, and second remark that a B-52 with nuclear bombs crashed 3 miles to the south in January of 1961. You can locate the intersection easily with a quick google search and a mapping tool. Indeed, one does not know what today will bring. They're strong photos of a specific kind, of a specific kind of Americana,
juxtaposed in a witty way which is nevertheless more than just the joke. The pairing makes a legitimate philosophical statement.
The whole book is like this.
Not only is the book structurally and graphically interesting, though. It constitutes a kind of honest and affectionate portrait
of rural, small-town, North Carolina. It is, I think, clear that Tim feels a profound warmth and at the same time a certain
frustration and even disgust, with the state in which he lives, and where he has spent a lot of time. Perhaps he finds
irritating the constant drumbeat of religion, especially this kind of small-time vaguely venal religion. At the same time,
he can't leave it alone.
There is no sign that these are beautiful people or that there is anything special about them, or the communities they live
in. Indeed, the few people depicted at all are, as often as not, rendered anonymous. At the same time, there is an affection,
or at least a familiarity, from the photographer that comes through.
This is the kind of meaning that I aspire to. I am also in love with America, and frustrated, and disgusted by America.
Perhaps I am actually just projecting my own conceptions onto this book, but damn it, it seems to accept those projections
willingly even if it's not Tim's intention. I see the book as a kind of affectionate portrait of a dog who is dumb, ill-mannered,
but basically, somehow, a pretty decent dog, a dog you love in spite of and maybe because of its many, many, flaws.
I like this book a lot, and I am extremely happy to have bought it when the opportunity came along.