I noodled on these questions (see previous remarks for context) some. It is genuinely a muddled and confused situation, which is no excuse for writing and publishing muddled articles. Sarah Sentilles has apparently been writing this piece for a while, she cites an earlier version of it in the NYT in which she seems to rather more acknowledge the muddle, but doesn't sort it out much.
Amusingly, in the NYT piece she is still a 15 year veteran of doing this work, even though it was written nearly two years earlier than the vox piece, which suggests at least a modicum of "phoning it in" at this point.
Anyways, she's not wrong. I do believe that the research ("counting") has been done, and that when you see a dead person in the western media, that person's skin is brown almost without exception. But the why is not at all clear. The standard response, Sentilles' among them, is to say "well racism, duh" and leave it at that.
There are real issues here that we ought not to handwave away. First of all, there is a difference between the choices which lead a visual to be "put out there" one way or another, and separately, there is the impact that it has. These are entangled, but not the same, and one ought to at least nod at the difference if you want to pretend to some sort of authority here (nobody ever does.)
The second thing is that there are conflicting mechanisms in play in the "choice to publish" machinery.
We have, historically, a lot of pictures of Victorian era brown people with, yeah, a subtext of "look at these weirdos, we should totally run their lives, teach them to wear pants, and take their shit." The Victorians published photos of the quick and the dead, but this is correctly viewed as the origin in these trends. There are lynching photos with a subtext of "powerful/good whitey teaches the Negro a valuable albeit brief lesson." We have photo editors — possibly with brown skin themselves — who are adhering to style guides and only publishing photos of "distant" victims, who are usually brown.
Call these "racist" mechanics, loosely construed.
We also have Emmett Till's mother, holding an open casket funeral for her son. We also have the video of Ahmaud Arbery being distributed. We have people re-distributing lynching photos in order not to support racism but to oppose it. There is a whole category of distribution here.
Call these "anti-racist" mechanics, loosely construed.
All this material muddles together, and the result is that when we see a dead body on social media or in the news, the skin is almost invariably brown.
The critical insight here is, I think, that sometimes the counter to the oppressing move is identical to the oppressing move, especially in media, in communication. The usage of the n-word, or to a lesser degree the word bitch falls into precisely the same category. There are two common usages for these words, with meanings that are precisely opposite.
In the same way there are two precisely opposite meanings to the photograph or video of a brown person's death or corpse, and that meaning, like the n-word, depends entirely on context.
Like a lynching photo, the video of Ahmaud Arbery's last moments is no doubt being circulated with both meanings. In racist circles it probably bears captions and commentary that no thinking human being could abide. One hopes that the actual impact of this distribution is effectively nil. In that context, it supports an overtly racist agenda. In more public circles it is being distributed with precisely the opposite intent, and, it appears, having precisely the opposite effect. At any rate the armed truck-owning (well, let's be honest, it's probably a lease) monkeys have at any rate finally been arrested.
We have here two opposing ideological systems, both devoted to publishing brown death, neither with any interest in white death.
What we are seeing is, I think, a struggle not over whether brown people or white people deserve respect in death, or whatever, but specifically over how we ought to view the picture of the brown corpse. It is not, I think, that we're specifically elevating white people here (although I suppose that could be a knock on effect) but that there are forces which seek to downplay, and others which seek to uplift, the status of the brown person specifically in death.
The fact that the two forces are using the same methods is confusing. This does not excuse the muddled hand-waving that passes for discourse on this topic.
It is as if, in studying the battle of Waterloo, the researchers noted similar weapons and tactics on all sides, and gave up. When asked to explain Waterloo, they now simply wave their hands and say, "Napoleon, duh."
On the one hand, yes, Napoleon is to blame. Without racism there would, likewise, be no story here. But to try to explain Waterloo with a handwave and "Napoleon, duh" would be ludicrous. We should not put up with this sort of so-called reasoning elsewhere.
Tuesday, May 12, 2020
Monday, May 11, 2020
Brown Deaths vs. White Deaths
Aaaaand immediately after whining about some totally other project that means I'm not writing here, here's another short essay.
There is a standard bit of theory among Media Thinkers that gets rolled out a lot. It is that the deaths of black and brown people are represented in the media as less important than the deaths of white people, and the proof of this is invariably that we are shown the former, and not the latter.
I do not intend to specifically quibble with the conclusion, only what passes for the argument that arises to support it.
I see this argument most recently on vox.com, here: The viral video of ... which makes the point that pictures of various other deaths are suppressed in the media, while the death of Ahmaud Arbery has been made rather public. Weirdly, the piece simultaneously argues that this video specifically, and other similar imagery, has been powerful, while at the same time restating the thesis that these things render those black and brown deaths less important.
Sentilles drags out Nick Ut's photo as an example of a powerful change-inducing photo, which points to a powerful lack of research on her part. All you have to do is look at the date of Ut's photo to see that it was, in fact, very late in the game well after the changes we imagine it spurred were inexorably under way.
Weirdly, her piece seems to be specifically arguing exactly opposing positions, simultaneously. White deaths are being hidden from us, suppressed, they have zero impact, which makes them, somehow, the important ones? White people are afforded privacy to die unmarked, unknown, which means they are the important ones? Brown deaths, being paraded for our delectation, are impactful, powerful, fraught with meaning, and with the power to change, which somehow means they are the unimportant ones?
Emmett Till's mother insisted on an open casket funeral for a reason: to make her son's death matter.
This piece is particularly off key, because of course the video of Ahmaud Arbery's death has served to render his death, in the public eye, important. His death, which would have been private, unmarked, unimportant had the video not surfaced, has become important. And let me be clear: it is important. At this moment in history, in this nation, this is the imagery we need to see. With all respect to those of you who have lost family and friends, Arbery's death matters more to us as a people, and it should.
And it does, specifically because this video has been put out there. Arbery's death is in the media, and your mother's, your son's, your spouse's is not, because his matters more.
Try on this alternative view of the suppression and distribution of the photography of death: Perhaps white death is suppressed because we don't need to see it. Perhaps the ubiquitous visual of brown death is what we need. Perhaps it is not an engine of white supremacy, but an engine driving forward in gradual, painful, hard-won steps, inch by inch, toward an equal understanding, an equal valuation, of brown and black death versus white.
I don't believe that argument any more than I believe the other one. Nobody has demonstrated anything like a causal path here. I do not know what is true. I do not know if there is any particular relationship between the representations of death and the ways we, as a group of related cultures, perceive the people depicted or not in those representations. The point is that neither does anyone else.
The standard piece simply recites the standard thesis, and tries to simultaneously pretend that it's an amazing new insight the author has just had, and also completely obvious and no actual argument is necessary. One need only state the thesis and stand back, smiling proudly.
Not good enough. That is not an argument, and your entire paper is muddled. F.
There is a standard bit of theory among Media Thinkers that gets rolled out a lot. It is that the deaths of black and brown people are represented in the media as less important than the deaths of white people, and the proof of this is invariably that we are shown the former, and not the latter.
I do not intend to specifically quibble with the conclusion, only what passes for the argument that arises to support it.
I see this argument most recently on vox.com, here: The viral video of ... which makes the point that pictures of various other deaths are suppressed in the media, while the death of Ahmaud Arbery has been made rather public. Weirdly, the piece simultaneously argues that this video specifically, and other similar imagery, has been powerful, while at the same time restating the thesis that these things render those black and brown deaths less important.
Sentilles drags out Nick Ut's photo as an example of a powerful change-inducing photo, which points to a powerful lack of research on her part. All you have to do is look at the date of Ut's photo to see that it was, in fact, very late in the game well after the changes we imagine it spurred were inexorably under way.
Weirdly, her piece seems to be specifically arguing exactly opposing positions, simultaneously. White deaths are being hidden from us, suppressed, they have zero impact, which makes them, somehow, the important ones? White people are afforded privacy to die unmarked, unknown, which means they are the important ones? Brown deaths, being paraded for our delectation, are impactful, powerful, fraught with meaning, and with the power to change, which somehow means they are the unimportant ones?
Emmett Till's mother insisted on an open casket funeral for a reason: to make her son's death matter.
This piece is particularly off key, because of course the video of Ahmaud Arbery's death has served to render his death, in the public eye, important. His death, which would have been private, unmarked, unimportant had the video not surfaced, has become important. And let me be clear: it is important. At this moment in history, in this nation, this is the imagery we need to see. With all respect to those of you who have lost family and friends, Arbery's death matters more to us as a people, and it should.
And it does, specifically because this video has been put out there. Arbery's death is in the media, and your mother's, your son's, your spouse's is not, because his matters more.
Try on this alternative view of the suppression and distribution of the photography of death: Perhaps white death is suppressed because we don't need to see it. Perhaps the ubiquitous visual of brown death is what we need. Perhaps it is not an engine of white supremacy, but an engine driving forward in gradual, painful, hard-won steps, inch by inch, toward an equal understanding, an equal valuation, of brown and black death versus white.
I don't believe that argument any more than I believe the other one. Nobody has demonstrated anything like a causal path here. I do not know what is true. I do not know if there is any particular relationship between the representations of death and the ways we, as a group of related cultures, perceive the people depicted or not in those representations. The point is that neither does anyone else.
The standard piece simply recites the standard thesis, and tries to simultaneously pretend that it's an amazing new insight the author has just had, and also completely obvious and no actual argument is necessary. One need only state the thesis and stand back, smiling proudly.
Not good enough. That is not an argument, and your entire paper is muddled. F.
Not Dead
I find myself somewhat embroiled in some longer form writing about which, perhaps, more anon.
In the mean time, I made this yesterday. The children have been watching Star Wars movies so, naturally, when I pulled the kohlrabi from the bag, I mumbled "That's no moon, that's kohlrabi" to myself. Then I drafted the larger child to hold up one of mom's black yoga blankets (it's a horse blanket except more expensive, but the price has been amortized over 2 decades of use) in the shadow while I held up the vegetable in the light from the window, and a few seconds later here we are.
That's no moon! That's KOHLRABI!
You're welcome.
Of course, now I have jinxed it. I expect to die in the next few hours in a ludicrous accident involving a pen and a potato.
In the mean time, I made this yesterday. The children have been watching Star Wars movies so, naturally, when I pulled the kohlrabi from the bag, I mumbled "That's no moon, that's kohlrabi" to myself. Then I drafted the larger child to hold up one of mom's black yoga blankets (it's a horse blanket except more expensive, but the price has been amortized over 2 decades of use) in the shadow while I held up the vegetable in the light from the window, and a few seconds later here we are.
That's no moon! That's KOHLRABI!
You're welcome.
Of course, now I have jinxed it. I expect to die in the next few hours in a ludicrous accident involving a pen and a potato.
Thursday, May 7, 2020
Kooks
There's a story we hear in photographic circles from time to time. Someone, I think it's usually Koudelka, is visiting someone else, or hanging around with someone else. Early in the morning, Koudelka is found outside, snapping wildly. He explains that he has to shoot 3000 frames before sunup every day to keep his eye in, or something. Sometimes he's just dry shooting, without film, sometimes he has to shoot film. I think sometimes he's actually Kertész.
These stories are always trotted out as kind of breathless examples of the kind of dedication shown by so-and-so the great photographer. The implication is that greatness requires this sort of weird behavior.
My reaction to these stories is not oh wow, I need to spend a lot more time wandering around shooting random pictures but rather holy shit, what a kook.
Far be it from me to question a fellow's process. Maybe it truly was necessary for Koudelka to get up at 4am and run the shutter of his camera 100 times every day, I dunno. What I do know is that this isn't a useful exercise for me, and there's no particular evidence that it's a useful exercise for you.
There have been some pretty fair large format photographers over the years, and I am gonna go out on a limb and suggest that most of them weren't up with the dawn cranking out a couple dozen sheets of film just to keep their eye in. On the flip side, by the end of his life Garry Winogrand had gone completely 'round the bend and apparently couldn't stop mashing the shutter button. I've seen the contact sheets and there's nothing there.
By all means, do whatever works for you, whatever gives you joy. But don't assign yourself tedious chores because you think you have to, and don't feel guilty or inadequate because you don't assign yourself tedious chores.
As Doc says to Lightning McQueen: Find a groove that works for you
These stories are always trotted out as kind of breathless examples of the kind of dedication shown by so-and-so the great photographer. The implication is that greatness requires this sort of weird behavior.
My reaction to these stories is not oh wow, I need to spend a lot more time wandering around shooting random pictures but rather holy shit, what a kook.
Far be it from me to question a fellow's process. Maybe it truly was necessary for Koudelka to get up at 4am and run the shutter of his camera 100 times every day, I dunno. What I do know is that this isn't a useful exercise for me, and there's no particular evidence that it's a useful exercise for you.
There have been some pretty fair large format photographers over the years, and I am gonna go out on a limb and suggest that most of them weren't up with the dawn cranking out a couple dozen sheets of film just to keep their eye in. On the flip side, by the end of his life Garry Winogrand had gone completely 'round the bend and apparently couldn't stop mashing the shutter button. I've seen the contact sheets and there's nothing there.
By all means, do whatever works for you, whatever gives you joy. But don't assign yourself tedious chores because you think you have to, and don't feel guilty or inadequate because you don't assign yourself tedious chores.
As Doc says to Lightning McQueen: Find a groove that works for you
Tuesday, May 5, 2020
"Clematis"
This is the final version of my Sonata experiment, at least in the sense that I have no intention of tinkering with it further.
It arguably represents everything I know about sequencing. Make of that what you will. The price is a much more attractive $25, (formerly $10,000 for the version with inferior typography.) Buy it, or just flip through the preview. You might find something to like in it. It's a big world, full of possibility!
Sonata No. 1, "Clematis"
You're welcome.
It arguably represents everything I know about sequencing. Make of that what you will. The price is a much more attractive $25, (formerly $10,000 for the version with inferior typography.) Buy it, or just flip through the preview. You might find something to like in it. It's a big world, full of possibility!
Sonata No. 1, "Clematis"
You're welcome.
Sunday, May 3, 2020
Fiction and Truth
Here's a dog.
Looking at this photo, it might occur to you the dog is sad which isn't totally accurate. There were children on her couch, making it completely unusable for napping, which is upsetting, but mainly she suffers from RSF, resting sad face.
Anyways, the point is that you probably thought something about the dog. Had I shown you instead a drawing of a glum dog, you would not have thought about the dog, the real dog. You might have thought about the artist, what the artist intended, or perhaps about the inner life of the fictional dog. It's quite unlikely that you would have imagined a real dog in any of your ruminations.
This is the point of photographs, of most of them, anyways. They connect us to real things. We see a picture, and we unpack it into a real world. We imagine a moment in time, a place, in this real world in which we live, into which that photograph fits.
There are exceptions. If I photograph an automobile race made with toy cars, or a battle scene with toy soldiers, we're likely to snap back to that fictional, imaginary, universe. Many other photos flirt with the line between a staged fiction and some sort of reality (fashion, in which the props are real but the story fiction, etc.) Still, most photos, and certainly photos made explicitly in the documentary mode, will refer us back to some real world. We will attempt to make sense of them in that light.
Along the way, we pick up clues. It seems to be, in fact, that we are hungry for clues. There is some mystery to the documentary photograph which we seem to want to solve, so things like captions and titles assume surprising weight.
If a fellow presents us with a bunch of photos and calls the body of work "Bedford-Stuyvesant" we're likely to try to unpack the pictures into some sort of representation of a Brooklyn neighborhood. If instead he titles it "A Murder in Bedford-Stuyvesant" we're going to unpack the pictures into a representation of a singular, violent, event. Figures who appeared under the first title to be simply a smattering of citizens become, notionally, friends of the victim. The gun which was some sort of vague symbol of violence becomes, abruptly, not only a murder weapon but the murder weapon, and so on.
The first reading is, in the case I have in mind, quite false. That neighborhood simply doesn't look like that, despite all the photos having been taken in the neighborhood. The second reading, if we imagined the same project to be so retitled, is probably just as false. The gun depicted probably isn't the one that shot Davon Williams, Jr. It's possible, even likely, that the random characters shown had no particular relationship with Williams or with his killer.
The falsehood is of a different character, maybe. While Williams was probably not shot with that gun, he was shot with a gun. Some of the people shown certainly could be friends or relatives. The police shown certainly are investigating the murder in question, the location all the photos are taken in is indeed the block where the murder occured.
Would the pictures in this case cast Williams in the role of some "thug lyfe" stereotype? Maybe?
With the gun "explained" by the murder and thus kind of removed from coloring the rest of the pictures, perhaps we might read the baggy clothing and demeanor of the characters as hip-hop style rather than anything more nefarious.
Rather than the guns, drugs, whores, lookit these lowlifes! read the "Bed-Stuy" title leaves open to us, the "Murder" title might suggest a violence is terrible, look at these funky stylish people who were impacted by it.
All this depends, of course, on you. Am I reading Jens Krauer's pictures as buncha lowlifes because I am just a bigot, and interpret hip-hop style as criminal? I think that Jens opened with the gun might get me off the hook here, but it's not necessarily wrong. Maybe it is mostly me.
Anyways, regardless of my issues, these pictures are of the kind that we're going to try to fit into a world, a world we imagine is part of our own, real world. The title gives us a clue, and so we try to expand Jens photos into some notion of "Bedford-Stuyvesant" (or, in my scenario, into the much smaller, briefer, world of the circumstances of a murder). We create this imaginary world, we create a mental construct, to fit the pictures. If we see a gun, that mental construct contains a gun, and maybe a lot of guns.
I could title the dog picture in a number of ways. Lost Ball yields one impression, Mom Is Never Coming Home quite another. In reality, the dog's head is almost completely empty in that shot. There is nothing whatever going on in there except a vague dad clicky box looking at me?
However it pans out, this mental construct is, or at any rate reflects on, our conception of that world. We might conclude that the real dog is genuinely sad, or that Bedford-Stuyvesant is indeed place of violence and crime. We might be right, we might be wrong, but this is a thing we do when we take more than a superficial moment with a photo.
These are things with which we ought to concern ourselves.
Looking at this photo, it might occur to you the dog is sad which isn't totally accurate. There were children on her couch, making it completely unusable for napping, which is upsetting, but mainly she suffers from RSF, resting sad face.
Anyways, the point is that you probably thought something about the dog. Had I shown you instead a drawing of a glum dog, you would not have thought about the dog, the real dog. You might have thought about the artist, what the artist intended, or perhaps about the inner life of the fictional dog. It's quite unlikely that you would have imagined a real dog in any of your ruminations.
This is the point of photographs, of most of them, anyways. They connect us to real things. We see a picture, and we unpack it into a real world. We imagine a moment in time, a place, in this real world in which we live, into which that photograph fits.
There are exceptions. If I photograph an automobile race made with toy cars, or a battle scene with toy soldiers, we're likely to snap back to that fictional, imaginary, universe. Many other photos flirt with the line between a staged fiction and some sort of reality (fashion, in which the props are real but the story fiction, etc.) Still, most photos, and certainly photos made explicitly in the documentary mode, will refer us back to some real world. We will attempt to make sense of them in that light.
Along the way, we pick up clues. It seems to be, in fact, that we are hungry for clues. There is some mystery to the documentary photograph which we seem to want to solve, so things like captions and titles assume surprising weight.
If a fellow presents us with a bunch of photos and calls the body of work "Bedford-Stuyvesant" we're likely to try to unpack the pictures into some sort of representation of a Brooklyn neighborhood. If instead he titles it "A Murder in Bedford-Stuyvesant" we're going to unpack the pictures into a representation of a singular, violent, event. Figures who appeared under the first title to be simply a smattering of citizens become, notionally, friends of the victim. The gun which was some sort of vague symbol of violence becomes, abruptly, not only a murder weapon but the murder weapon, and so on.
The first reading is, in the case I have in mind, quite false. That neighborhood simply doesn't look like that, despite all the photos having been taken in the neighborhood. The second reading, if we imagined the same project to be so retitled, is probably just as false. The gun depicted probably isn't the one that shot Davon Williams, Jr. It's possible, even likely, that the random characters shown had no particular relationship with Williams or with his killer.
The falsehood is of a different character, maybe. While Williams was probably not shot with that gun, he was shot with a gun. Some of the people shown certainly could be friends or relatives. The police shown certainly are investigating the murder in question, the location all the photos are taken in is indeed the block where the murder occured.
Would the pictures in this case cast Williams in the role of some "thug lyfe" stereotype? Maybe?
With the gun "explained" by the murder and thus kind of removed from coloring the rest of the pictures, perhaps we might read the baggy clothing and demeanor of the characters as hip-hop style rather than anything more nefarious.
Rather than the guns, drugs, whores, lookit these lowlifes! read the "Bed-Stuy" title leaves open to us, the "Murder" title might suggest a violence is terrible, look at these funky stylish people who were impacted by it.
All this depends, of course, on you. Am I reading Jens Krauer's pictures as buncha lowlifes because I am just a bigot, and interpret hip-hop style as criminal? I think that Jens opened with the gun might get me off the hook here, but it's not necessarily wrong. Maybe it is mostly me.
Anyways, regardless of my issues, these pictures are of the kind that we're going to try to fit into a world, a world we imagine is part of our own, real world. The title gives us a clue, and so we try to expand Jens photos into some notion of "Bedford-Stuyvesant" (or, in my scenario, into the much smaller, briefer, world of the circumstances of a murder). We create this imaginary world, we create a mental construct, to fit the pictures. If we see a gun, that mental construct contains a gun, and maybe a lot of guns.
I could title the dog picture in a number of ways. Lost Ball yields one impression, Mom Is Never Coming Home quite another. In reality, the dog's head is almost completely empty in that shot. There is nothing whatever going on in there except a vague dad clicky box looking at me?
However it pans out, this mental construct is, or at any rate reflects on, our conception of that world. We might conclude that the real dog is genuinely sad, or that Bedford-Stuyvesant is indeed place of violence and crime. We might be right, we might be wrong, but this is a thing we do when we take more than a superficial moment with a photo.
These are things with which we ought to concern ourselves.
Saturday, May 2, 2020
Well, This is Bad
Here's a recent photo essay thing on The Phoblographer: Bed-Stuy which is the usual sort of thing.
Fujifilm Ambassador Jens Krauer goes on and on about what it truly means to be a street photographer, and how he just keeps coming back and back to New York over the years and he's doing this study of the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood. You'd be forgiven for thinking that he claims to have been working on his "Bed-Stuy" project for a long time, but I don't think he actually says that, and as we shall see he, um, hasn't been.
The first thing we might notice is that it is always nighttime in Bed-Stuy, that all the citizens are black, all the cops are non-black. Jens gives us a kind of noir-meets-hip-hop fantasy here. He leads with a gun, then shows us what we're probably supposed to think is drugs (is that pigeon shit in that guy's hand, or what?) what we are probably supposed to think is a hooker with her pimp, a cast of Characters, some police activity, a shrine to a murder victim, and some random urban shit.
The look is gritty and urban, standard nighttime "street" and, honestly, pretty solid examples of the genre. Spill a little gin on the ground for Weegee.
It turns out there are non-black people in Bedford-Stuyvesant, some people hardly do crime at all and daytime happens there from time to time, so this is a fantasy we're looking at, and a fantasy which is trafficking in unsavory stereotypes. This is more or less exactly the kind of thing people who worry about "representation" in photography worry about, and not without reason. This is in no meaningful way Bedford-Stuyvesant, it is at the very best a very very narrow slice of the culture there, and it is largely a construct.
But wait, there's more!
Let's run through the photos quickly and establish their locations:
Gun — no idea
Inside Shop — could be any shop, but I have a guess
man on bench — bench outside the NBA Deli at Nostrand & Halsey
window shrine — no idea
man in shop doorway — NBA deli
man on bench — bench outside NBA deli
drugs(?) — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
hulking silhouette — NBA deli
two rings — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
guy in doorway — NBA deli
people hugging — crosswalk outside NBA deli
guy getting out of car — 1-2 storefronts up Nostrand fron NBA deli
couple — NBA deli (shop door is 10 feet frame right)
dude with R — NBA deli
girl — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police activity — Arlington St, 1.5 blocks from NBA deli
broken bottle — no idea
shrine — across the street from NBA deli
A few more interesting facts. The guy in the THIS IS WHAT NEW YORK LOOKS LIKE tee is the same as the guy in his undershirt in the shop doorway. The guy getting out of his car is pointing guy, and I think also the guy holding the gun. The police action around the NBA deli is in response to the murder for the young man memorialized in the shrine. The police action on Arlington might have been the same activity (the news reports indicate they were looking for the shooter, and note that it is raining in the shot.)
These photos, which masterfully appear to be of a number of locations, are all actually taken in pretty much the same place. For more than half of them, the photographer is in the same 20 foot circle, just pointing his camera differently. The graffiti, the stickers, the foliage, and often the trash, remain the same frame to frame. These photos were, for the most part, shot within a few days of one another, on a single street corner. The cast of characters is somewhat smaller than it appears at first, you don't notice all the dupes unless you're really paying attention.
Not only is the culturally a very very tiny slice of life in Bedford-Stuyvesant, it's geographically miniscule as well.
This is some mook who's got an AirBnB for a week around the corner, and headed down to this shop two or three nights to bang out some snaps. There was a shooting one night, so he got some shots of cops doing cop shit, went out the next day to photograph the victim's shrine across the street and a few doors up Nostrand.
What really appalls me here is that he's fairly skilled.
He's taken a small set of lazily made snaps from a single street corner, and somehow managed to convincingly tell a story of crime and poverty about an entire neighborhood. Without the murder to spice things up, of course, he wouldn't have had anything much, but with it he can hang his shitty story on it, and sell it.
I mean, it's on The Phoblographer, so you know it's gonna be kind of s shit show, but seriously. This is awful.
Yes, I spent too much time on Google Street View, and reading old news reports yesterday, but honestly, it wasn't very hard to assemble all this stuff. You just have to open your eyes and look.
Fujifilm Ambassador Jens Krauer goes on and on about what it truly means to be a street photographer, and how he just keeps coming back and back to New York over the years and he's doing this study of the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood. You'd be forgiven for thinking that he claims to have been working on his "Bed-Stuy" project for a long time, but I don't think he actually says that, and as we shall see he, um, hasn't been.
The first thing we might notice is that it is always nighttime in Bed-Stuy, that all the citizens are black, all the cops are non-black. Jens gives us a kind of noir-meets-hip-hop fantasy here. He leads with a gun, then shows us what we're probably supposed to think is drugs (is that pigeon shit in that guy's hand, or what?) what we are probably supposed to think is a hooker with her pimp, a cast of Characters, some police activity, a shrine to a murder victim, and some random urban shit.
The look is gritty and urban, standard nighttime "street" and, honestly, pretty solid examples of the genre. Spill a little gin on the ground for Weegee.
It turns out there are non-black people in Bedford-Stuyvesant, some people hardly do crime at all and daytime happens there from time to time, so this is a fantasy we're looking at, and a fantasy which is trafficking in unsavory stereotypes. This is more or less exactly the kind of thing people who worry about "representation" in photography worry about, and not without reason. This is in no meaningful way Bedford-Stuyvesant, it is at the very best a very very narrow slice of the culture there, and it is largely a construct.
But wait, there's more!
Let's run through the photos quickly and establish their locations:
Gun — no idea
Inside Shop — could be any shop, but I have a guess
man on bench — bench outside the NBA Deli at Nostrand & Halsey
window shrine — no idea
man in shop doorway — NBA deli
man on bench — bench outside NBA deli
drugs(?) — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
hulking silhouette — NBA deli
two rings — no idea
pointing guy — NBA deli
guy in doorway — NBA deli
people hugging — crosswalk outside NBA deli
guy getting out of car — 1-2 storefronts up Nostrand fron NBA deli
couple — NBA deli (shop door is 10 feet frame right)
dude with R — NBA deli
girl — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police tape — NBA deli
police activity — Arlington St, 1.5 blocks from NBA deli
broken bottle — no idea
shrine — across the street from NBA deli
A few more interesting facts. The guy in the THIS IS WHAT NEW YORK LOOKS LIKE tee is the same as the guy in his undershirt in the shop doorway. The guy getting out of his car is pointing guy, and I think also the guy holding the gun. The police action around the NBA deli is in response to the murder for the young man memorialized in the shrine. The police action on Arlington might have been the same activity (the news reports indicate they were looking for the shooter, and note that it is raining in the shot.)
These photos, which masterfully appear to be of a number of locations, are all actually taken in pretty much the same place. For more than half of them, the photographer is in the same 20 foot circle, just pointing his camera differently. The graffiti, the stickers, the foliage, and often the trash, remain the same frame to frame. These photos were, for the most part, shot within a few days of one another, on a single street corner. The cast of characters is somewhat smaller than it appears at first, you don't notice all the dupes unless you're really paying attention.
Not only is the culturally a very very tiny slice of life in Bedford-Stuyvesant, it's geographically miniscule as well.
This is some mook who's got an AirBnB for a week around the corner, and headed down to this shop two or three nights to bang out some snaps. There was a shooting one night, so he got some shots of cops doing cop shit, went out the next day to photograph the victim's shrine across the street and a few doors up Nostrand.
What really appalls me here is that he's fairly skilled.
He's taken a small set of lazily made snaps from a single street corner, and somehow managed to convincingly tell a story of crime and poverty about an entire neighborhood. Without the murder to spice things up, of course, he wouldn't have had anything much, but with it he can hang his shitty story on it, and sell it.
I mean, it's on The Phoblographer, so you know it's gonna be kind of s shit show, but seriously. This is awful.
Yes, I spent too much time on Google Street View, and reading old news reports yesterday, but honestly, it wasn't very hard to assemble all this stuff. You just have to open your eyes and look.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


